Since 2010, the Massachusetts Office of Coastal Zone Management (CZM) has been using infaunal grab samples (sediment samples sieved to reveal the small, sediment-dwelling animals) and seafloor imagery to map the distribution, and in some instances the abundance and relationships, of flora and fauna in Massachusetts marine waters. This web page describes the following biological mapping tasks conducted by CZM:

Infauna Collection

CZM and its partners, the Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries (MarineFisheries) and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), began sampling for marine infauna (small sediment-dwelling organisms) in 2010. Using the EPA Ocean Survey Vessel Bold as a platform and a 0.04 square-meter modified Van Veen grab, CZM collected 100 infauna samples in Cape Cod Bay in 2010. The data from this project were published in Sediment Grain Size and Benthic Infaunal Analysis in Support of CZM's Survey on the OSV Bold: Validation of Seafloor Sediment Maps in Massachusetts Bay and Cape Cod Bay pdf format of benthic-infauna-report-2010.pdf file size 5MB . During Bold research cruises in 2011 and 2012, which included the use of the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) SEABOSS (Sea Bottom Observation and Sampling System) sampling system, CZM gathered 214 infauna samples south of Cape Cod and 207 infauna samples north of Boston (in 2011 and 2012 respectively). The 2011 data were published in ENV12 CZM 01 Benthic Infaunal Analysis Report pdf format of benthic-infauna-report-2011.pdf file size 14MB , and the 2012 data were published in ENV13 CZM 01 Benthic Infaunal Analysis Report pdf format of ENV13 CZM 01 Benthic Infaunal Analysis Report file size 2MB .

Infaunal Samples

Locations of all infauna samples collected by CZM and its partners between 2010 and 2012. Click to see the full size image pdf format of bold-infauna-samples.pdf

CZM uses the infauna, seafloor sediment, and depth data collected at each sample site to identify distinct infaunal communities in Massachusetts (as seen in the circled areas in the figure below). These types of patterns in infauna communities can be used to identify not only the most common communities, but also the rarest. The data can also help to identify areas that have the highest and lowest densities of infauna and to determine which types of infaunal organisms (e.g., crustaceans, worms, or clams) dominate a particular area of the coast.

Infaunal Communities in Cape Cod Bay

Infaunal communities identified in Cape Cod Bay in 2011. Sampling locations are identified as colored shapes (squares or triangles). The color of a sampling location represents the seafloor sediment type at that location (blue = mud, yellow = sand, orange = gravel). Like infaunal communities are located within ovals of similar color. For example, the communities in pink ovals share 65% of the same infauna families. Click to see the full size image pdf format of bold-2011-infaunal-communities.pdf

Photo and Video Interpretation

To date, over 10,000 images of the seafloor have been obtained from the CZM-USGS Seafloor Mapping Cooperative and the Bold surveys. Each photo or video-screen capture contains information on the seafloor sediment in a given location, in addition to habitat structures and their associated organisms. CZM is using this imagery data to help categorize and map important habitats and species-habitat associations. For example, kelp is a type of canopy forming algae that serves as a habitat and food source for many species. The imagery of the seafloor can be used to determine where these canopy forming species are in the region and what habitat and locations they occupy.

Kelp in Boston Harbor

A map of canopy forming algae (kelp) distribution derived from photos in the Nahant to Gloucester and Boston Harbor CZM-USGS Seafloor Mapping Cooperative and the Bold 2012 datasets. These data were overlaid with bathymetry to demonstrate the preference of these species for areas with hard, rocky substrate for attachment. Click to see the full size image pdf format of bh-kelp-bathy.pdf

Biological Classification System

The biological information in the imagery is classified according to a modified version of the Coastal and Marine Ecological Classification Standard (CMECS) Version 4.0, Benthic Biotic Component, to standardize the way the photos are used and analyzed. CMECS, a Federal Geographic Data Committee standard, is a hierarchal system that provides a means for classifying ecological units using a standard format.

In the CMECS Benthic Biotic Component, biotic classification is defined by the dominance of stable, fixed (sessile), or slow moving species visible in the photo. Since more than one group of organisms is sometimes captured in the photos, and some species may be present but not necessarily be recorded in the classification scheme (such as fish, crabs, etc.), two co-occurring biotic groups and two associated taxa are also included in the classification system. See the photo below of kelp, other algae species, sponges, and sea stars for an example of how the photographs are classified for mapping and analysis purposes.

Biotic Class: Aquatic Vegetation Bed

Biotic Subclass: Benthic Macroalgae

Biotic Group: Canopy-Forming Algal Bed

Co-Occurring Modifier 1: Coralline/Crustose Algal Bed

Co-Occurring Modifier 2: Filamentous Algal Bed

Associated Taxa Modifier 1: Porifera (sponge)

Associated Taxa Modifier 2: Henricia sanguinolenta (blood star)

Benthic Classification

Photograph from the Bold 2012 survey of Agarum clathratum (canopy forming algae), crustose (bubblegum) algae, filamentous algae, sponges, and other species, with accompanying CMECS Benthic Biotic Component Classification (see above). Click to see the full size image pdf format of cmecs-benthic-classification.pdf

CZM is also analyzing seafloor images to evaluate the Massachusetts Ocean Management Plan’s “Hard/Complex Seafloor” map to determine which organisms and groups of organisms are typically found within the boundaries of the mapped Special, Sensitive, or Unique resource areas identified in the plan. Since the Hard/Complex Seafloor map was developed based on information about the seafloor bottom, this will give CZM a better idea of what organisms are present in these habitats and thus protected under this aspect of the Massachusetts Ocean Management Plan.

Canopy Forming Algae Map

A map of canopy forming algae (kelps) classified from photos in the CZM-USGS Seafloor Mapping Cooperative and the Bold survey datasets overlaid with the Massachusetts Ocean Management Plan’s Hard/Complex Seafloor map. Click to see the full size image pdf format of canopy-forming-algae-map.pdf