The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
——————
PETITION OF:
——————
In the Year Two Thousand and Seven.
——————
|
An Act establishing judicial jurisdiction over certain individuals including those on conditional release. |
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Court assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:
SECTION
1. Section 1 of chapter 123, as appearing in the 1994 Official Edition, is hereby
amended by inserting after the words “the following meanings”, in line 3, the
following paragraph:—
“Acquittee”, any person who has been adjudicated not guilty by reason of mental
disease or defect. “Board”, the psychiatric security review board.
SECTION 2. Section
1 of chapter 123, as so appearing, is hereby further amended by inserting after
the words “limit freedom of movement”, in line 83, the following paragraph:—
“Serious bodily injury”, bodily injury that creates a permanent disfigurement,
protracted loss or impairment of a function of a body member, limb or organ, or
substantial risk of death.
SECTION 3. Chapter
123, as so appearing, is hereby amended by inserting after section 1 the
following section:—
Section 1A. (a) There shall be in the department, but not subject to its
jurisdiction, a board, consisting of five members, to be appointed by the
governor, with the advice and consent of the council, for terms of five years.
(b) The membership of the board shall be composed of a psychologist with
expertise in forensic psychology, who shall initially be appointed to a term of
three years; a psychiatrist with expertise in forensic psychiatry; a member of
the general public who shall initially be appointed for a term of three years;
an attorney who is a member of the bar of the commonwealth, who shall initially
be appointed for a term of three years; and a person qualified by knowledge,
education, or experience in the administration of criminal justice.
(c) The board shall have jurisdiction over persons committed to its authority
by a court of competent jurisdiction, pursuant to paragraph (d) of section
sixteen C of this chapter; may revise, alter or amend the conditions of release
pursuant to paragraph (a) of section seventeen A of this chapter; shall
supervise all persons committed to its jurisdiction, make such investigations
as may be necessary in connection therewith, determine whether violations of
conditional release exist in specific cases, and decide the action to be taken
thereto.
SECTION 4. Chapter
123, as so appearing, is hereby amended by inserting after section 16 the
following sections:
Section 16A. (a) When a defendant charged with an offense involving a
substantial risk of serious bodily injury or death, or actual bodily injury, is
found not guilty by reason of mental illness or defect of the offense charged,
the court having jurisdiction over the criminal proceedings shall order that
the acquittee be hospitalized for examination and observation at a public
facility, a private facility licensed by the department to perform forensic
evaluations or, if the person is a male, at the Bridgewater state hospital.
Such period of examination shall not exceed forty days unless, before the
expiration of such forty day period, the facility superintendent or medical
director of the Bridgewater state hospital believes that observation for more
than forty days is necessary. In such event, the superintendent or medical
director shall so notify the court, in writing, that an extension of the forty
day period is necessary, specifying the reason or reasons for which further
observation is necessary. Upon receipt of such request, the court may extend
said observation period, but in no event shall the period exceed sixty days
from the date of the initial court order for hospitalization.
(b) At the conclusion of the examination or the observation period, the
examining physician or psychologist shall forthwith provide the court with a
written, signed, report of his findings on the issue of whether the acquittee
is mentally ill and the discharge of such person from a facility would create a
likelihood of serious harm. The court shall provide such reports to the
district attorney with jurisdiction of the criminal case, and to the defendant
or his counsel, and shall notify such parties and the superintendent or medical
director with custody of the defendant of the date on which the court will hold
a hearing to determine whether the defendant shall be committed for further
treatment in accordance with section sixteen B of this chapter. The hearing
shall be held as soon as practicable, but in no event more than seventy-five
days from the date of the initial court order for hospitalization pursuant to
paragraph (a) of this section. Pending hearing and decision rendered pursuant
too paragraph (b) of section sixteen B of this chapter, the acquittee shall be
held at the facility or Bridgewater state hospital.
(c) Upon motion by the district attorney or the attorney for the acquittee, the
court shall order the defendant to be examined by a separate expert, who shall
have access to all records of the acquittee and who shall file with the court a
written, signed, report of such expert’s findings on the issue of whether the
defendant is mentally ill and the discharge of such person from a facility
would create a likelihood of serious harm. The court shall provide such reports
to all parties entitled to notice of the hearing pursuant to paragraph (b) of
this section.
(d) For purposes of this section and section sixteen B of this chapter, a
mentally ill person shall mean any person presently suffering from a mental
illness, or suffering from mental illness in a state of remission when the
illness may, with reasonable medical probability, become active.
Section 16B. (a) Notwithstanding the procedures for civil commitment set forth
elsewhere in this chapter, when a defendant charged with an offense involving a
substantial risk of serious bodily injury or death, actual bodily injury, is
found not guilty by reason of mental illness or defect of the offense charged,
the court having jurisdiction over the criminal proceedings shall commit the
acquittee to the department or, if the person is a male and the court finds
that failure to retain the acquittee in strict custody would create a substantial
likelihood of harm to himself or others, to Bridgewater state hospital, upon a
finding, after hearing pursuant to paragraph (b) of section sixteen A of this
chapter, that such acquittee is mentally ill and the discharge of such person
from a facility would create a likelihood of serious harm.
The hearing shall be a civil proceeding, and the burden of proof shall be upon
the commonwealth to prove by clear and convincing evidence that the acquittee
is mentally ill and the discharge of such person from a facility would create a
likelihood of serious harm. No commitment shall be ordered to Bridgewater
state hospital unless the acquittee is a male and the’ court finds that the
failure to retain the acquittee in strict custody would create a substantial
likelihood of harm to himself or others by reason of mental illness or defect.
The acquittee may waive his right to such hearing in writing with the advice
and consent of counsel. In the event that the acquittee so waives his right to
a hearing, the court may order the acquittee’s commitment upon evidence from a
qualified expert that the acquittee is mentally ill.
(b) The court shall render its decision within ten days of the completion of
the hearing or, if the hearing has been waived, within ten days of the submission
of expert evidence on the acquittee’s mental condition provided that, for
reasons stated in writing by the court, the administrative justice for the
district court department may extend said ten day period.
(c) The court shall fix a maximum term of commitment, which shall not exceed
the maximum sentence that could have been imposed if the acquittee had been
convicted of the most serious offense charged. Such term of commitment may be
extended only in accordance with civil commitment procedures set forth in
section eight of this chapter.
The court may further order any acquittee committed pursuant to this section to
be restricted in his movements to the buildings and grounds of the facility or Bridgewater
state hospital. If such restrictions are ordered, they shall not be removed
except with the approval of the court.
(d) Each acquittee committed pursuant to this section shall be subject to
periodic review in accordance with the provisions of section four of this
chapter. An annual report, based on such review, shall be forwarded to the
court with jurisdiction of the criminal case, or to the court with jurisdiction
of the facility to which the acquittee has been committed or Bridgewater state
hospital, provided that jurisdiction has been transferred. Such report shall
contain an opinion, supported by clinical findings, as to whether the acquittee
is in need of continued hospitalization or other treatment offered by the
department or Bridgewater state hospital.
Section 16C. (a) If, at any time prior to the expiration of a term of
commitment ordered pursuant to paragraph (c) of section sixteen B of this
chapter, any person believes that an acquittee committed for treatment under
such section no longer presents a substantial risk of serious bodily injury or death
to others, a substantial risk of an imminent threat of physical injury to the
acquittee himself or others, resulting from mental illness or defect, he shall
petition for the conditional release of the acquittee to the court that
committed the acquittee, or to the court of jurisdiction of the facility to
which the acquittee has been committed or of Bridgewater state hospital,
providing the committing court consents to the transfer of jurisdiction.
(b) Within seven days of receiving a petition made pursuant to paragraph (a) of
this section, the court shall order notice of the time and place for hearing to
be given to the superintendent or medical director with custody of the
committed acquittee, the district attorney of the district from which the person
was committed, and such other persons as he considers proper; and such hearing
shall be held promptly. The court shall appoint an attorney to represent any
applicant whom it finds to be indigent.
The applicant or the committed acquittee may retain an expert to testify at the
hearing. If the person wishing to secure such expert testimony is unable to
afford the expert’s fee, the court shall appoint an additional qualified
psychologist or qualified psychiatrist to perform an examination. Upon motion
by the district attorney or the superintendent or medical director, the court
shall order such person to be examined by a separate expert, who shall have
access to all records of the acquittee. If the committed acquittee refuses,
without good cause, to be interviewed by an expert as ordered under this
section, such acquittee shall be deemed to have waived his right to a hearing
on his petition, and the petition shall be dismissed upon motion filed by the
district attorney or the superintendent or medical director.
Any expert who conducts an examination of the committed acquittee shall file
with the court a written, signed, report of such expert’s findings on the
issues of.whether such person is mentally ill and whether such person presents
a substantial risk of serious bodily injury or death to others, a substantial
risk of an imminent threat of physical injury to the person or others. The
court shall provide such report to the committed acquittee and all persons
entitled to notice under paragraph (b) of this section.
The person who is the subject of the petition may be brought before the court
at the hearing upon a writ of habeas corpus, upon a request approved by the
court. Pending the decision of the court, such person shall be retained in the
custody of the superintendent or medical director.
(c) Hearings on petition for the release of a person committed pursuant to
section sixteen B of this chapter shall not be held more than once a year,
unless all parties requiring notice of such hearing consent thereto.
(d) If the court decides that the person no longer presents a substantial risk
of serious bodily injury or death to the person or others, a substantial risk
of an imminent threat of physical injury to the person or others, and can be
properly monitored on conditions necessary for ensuring the safety of the
person and others including, but not limited to, conditions requiring continued
medications or other treatment, the court shall commit the person to the
psychiatric security review board for the remainder of the 166 period of
commitment imposed under paragraph (c) of section sixteen B of this chapter,
provided that no person shall be released directly from Bridgewater state
hospital.
(e) At a hearing for release on conditions of any person committed pursuant to
section sixteen B of this chapter, the petitioner shall bear the burden of
proof, by a preponderance of the evidence.
SECTION 5. Chapter
123, as so appearing, is hereby amended by inserting after section 17 the
following sections:
Section 17A. (a) The psychiatric security review board shall conduct a hearing
to set conditions of release within thirty days of transfer of commitment
pursuant to paragraph (d) of section sixteen C of this chapter. Pending the
hearing before the board, the person’s placement shall remain unchanged.
(b) Not less than fifteen days prior to a hearing before the board, the
department shall submit to the board reports and records relative to the
person’s need for continued care and treatment in the community. Copies of any
materials furnished to the board shall be provided to the committed person or
his representative, and to counsel for the commonwealth.
(c) The board may require any person committed to its jurisdiction to submit to
an examination by a qualified psychiatrist or psychologist, chosen by the
board. A written report of the examination shall be submitted to the board not
less than ten days prior to a hearing pursuant to this section. Copies of the
report shall be furnished to the committed person or his representative, and to
counsel for the commonwealth.
Section 17B. The board shall designate a capable person or appropriate public
or private agency to supervise the committed person’s compliance with the
conditions imposed on his release by the board.
Section 17C. (a) Any person may apply to the board for the modification of the
terms of conditional release ordered by the board. An application for
modification shall be accompanied by a statement setting forth the facts in
support of the application. The board shall send copies of such application and
statement to the person who is the subject of conditional release, or his
representative, and to counsel for the commonwealth.
(b) The board shall commence a hearing for review of such application no more
than thirty days after its receipt of the application.
(c) An application for modification by a person subject to release conditions
shall not be filed more than once every six months.
Section 17D. If a determination is made by the board that a person committed to
its jurisdiction has violated a condition of release, the board may restrain or
authorize the restraint of the person for a period not to exceed three days,
excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays. Prior to the conclusion of
the calculated three day period, the board shall either release the person on
such conditions as it deems necessary for the safety of the person or others,
or petition a court of competent jurisdiction for the revocation of conditional
release. A hearing on such petition shall be commenced no longer than ten days
after the filing of the petition with the court. Notice of the petition and
hearing shall be given to the person or his representative, and to counsel for
the commonwealth.
Section 17E. The psychiatric security review board shall not have the authority
to discharge a person committed to its jurisdiction from commitment to its
jurisdiction.
Section 17F. (a) The court may order revocation of a person’s release on
conditions if the court. determines, upon a preponderance of the evidence, after
hearing, that (1) the conditions of release have not been fulfilled; and (2)
based on the violations of the conditions and the person’s past mental health
history, there is a substantial likelihood that the person continues to suffer
from a mental illness that causes the person to present a substantial risk of
serious bodily injury or death to the person or others, or an imminent threat
of physical injury to the person or others.
(b) The court may retain jurisdiction to revoke a conditional release for no
longer than the period of commitment ordered pursuant to paragraph (c) of
section sixteen B of this chapter.
(c) If the court finds that the conditional release should be revoked, the
court shall immediately order the person recommitted to the custody of the
superintendent who had custody of the committed person prior to his release,
or, if the person is a male and the court finds that the failure to retain such
person in strict security could create a likelihood of serious harm, the court
shall commit the person to Bridgewater state hospital.
Section 17G. (a) Victims and family members, as defined in section one of
chapter two hundred and fifty-eight B, shall be permitted to attend all
proceedings held pursuant to sections sixteen B, sixteen C, seventeen C and
seventeen F of this chapter. These proceedings shall be open to the public a
aicss the judge, in his discretion, makes a determination that the proceedings
should be close to the public in the interest of justice.
(b) Prior to the conditional release or discharge of any person committed
pursuant to sections sixteen B, sixteen C, seventeen C, or seventeen F of this
chapter, the district attorney with jurisdiction over the initial criminal
proceedings shall take reasonable steps to notify victims and family members,
as defined in section one of chapter two hundred and fifty-eight B, of such
release or discharge.
SECTION 6. Chapter
123, as so appearing, is hereby amended by inserting after section 30 the
following section:—
Section 30A. It shall be a criminal act, as set forth in section sixteen B of
chapter two hundred and sixty-eight, for a person committed to a facility,
Bridgewater state hospital, or the jurisdiction of the psychiatric security
review board, pursuant to the provisions of sections fifteen, sixteen, sixteen
B, sixteen C, seventeen, seventeen F, or eighteen to be absent without
authorization as defined in this chapter.
SECTION 7. Chapter
268, as appearing in the 1994 Official Edition, is hereby amended by inserting
after section 16A the following section:—
Section 16B. A person committed to a facility, Bridgewater state hospital, or
the jurisdiction of the psychiatric security review board, pursuant to the
provisions of sections fifteen, sixteen, sixteen B, sixteen C, seventeen,
seventeen F, or eighteen, who is absent without authorization from a facility,
Bridgewater state hospital, of who, while committed to the jurisdiction of the
psychiatric security review board, leaves the commonwealth without written
authorization from the psychiatric security review board, may be pursued and
shall be recaptured and returned to the facility from which he escaped or was
absent without authorization, Bridgewater state hospital or, in the case of a
person committed to the jurisdiction of the psychiatric security review board,
the last facility in which he was hospitalized.