Company Name

Complaints in 2011

Market Share in MA

Commerce Insurance Company

98

28.40%

Liberty Mutual Insurance Company

52

11.40%

Safety Insurance Company

37

10.98%

Arbella Mutual Insurance Company

35

8.79%

Plymouth Rock Assurance Corporation

21

5.47%

Metropolitan Property and Casualty Ins. Company

22

4.86%

Premier Insurance Company of Massachusetts, (The)

22

4.45%

Amica Mutual Insurance Company

4

3.48%

Citizens Insurance Company of America

20

2.95%

Progressive Direct Insurance Company

24

2.93%

Government Employees Insurance Company

20

2.34%

Quincy Mutual Fire Insurance Company

7

1.72%

USAA Casualty Insurance Company

6

1.31%

NGM Insurance Company

5

1.27%

Norfolk & Dedham Mutual Fire Insurance Company

9

1.19%

Massachusetts Homeland Insurance Company

3

1.18%

Encompass Insurance Company of Massachusetts

4

1.01%

United Services Automobile Association

7

0.96%

Vermont Mutual Insurance Company

2

0.95%

Peerless Insurance Company

8

0.71%

Occidental Fire & Casualty Company of N. Carolina

7

0.56%

Allstate Insurance Company

9

0.43%

GEICO Indemnity Company

1

0.41%

State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company

3

0.40%

Pilgrim Insurance Company

6

0.34%

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

4

0.33%

Electric Insurance Company

3

0.26%

Harleysville Worcester Insurance Company

1

0.17%

Farm Family Casualty Insurance Company

1

0.13%

Mount Vernon Fire Insurance Company

1

0.07%

Hanover Insurance Company

4

0.04%

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company

2

0.03%

American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida

1

0.01%

GEICO General Insurance Company

5

0.00%

Recommended Content

People also viewed...

You recently viewed...

Personalization is OFF. Your personal browsing history at Mass.gov is not visible because your personalization is turned off. To view your history, turn your personalization on.

Learn more on our .

*Recommendations are based on site visitor traffic patterns and are not endorsements of that content.