Dear Mr. Wassam,

My name is Jim Smith and I am from Brookline here in Massachusetts. I am emailing in regards to the proposed updates to the Department of Energy Resources (DOER) RPS Class I and RPS Class II regulations.

I urge DOER to remove the proposed addition in eligibility criteria for hydropower under Class I in 225 CMR 14.05 (1)(a)(6), new paragraph h, that reads as follows, “A Generation Unit that has received a certification from LIHI and a Statement of Qualification from the Department shall not be required to obtain a recertification from LIHI in order to retain its Statement of Qualification.

I am very interested in knowing the name of the individual who formulated this new language and how it came to be added the proposed regulations.

Removing a requirement for recertification from the Low Impact Hydropower Institute (LIHI) would effectively undermine a hydropower operator’s motivation to improve their systems and minimize their environmental impact over time on rivers. A qualified project would effectively receive a lifetime qualification regardless of any environmental changes or technological advances that would prompt updated conditions to protect river systems. This is poor policy and a poor idea. It is not in the best interests of the citizens of our commonwealth.

Being certified by LIHI means a hydropower facility must pass rigorous standards for river flows, water quality, fish passage and protection, watershed protection, threatened and endangered species protection, cultural resource protection, and recreation. It’s important to me that we maintain LIHI annual compliance reviews and re-certifications every 5-10 years to allow for updated assessments of changing environmental conditions as well as stakeholder and agency. Nearly 65% of projects that recertify contain updated conditions that are new or different from a previous certification. Upgrades have included improved fish and eel passage requirements which are important for the health of river systems.

Please remove this new paragraph in the proposed regulations and maintain the original language. The recertification requirement has made a big difference in reducing hydropower impacts on rivers – let’s maintain that for the future.

Jim Smith

119 Crafts Road

Chestnut Hill, MA