The Commission overturned MassDOT's decision to terminate the Appellant as MassDOT failed to show, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the Appellant engaged in the alleged misconduct.
The Superior Court affirmed the Commission's decision allowing the Appellant's promotional bypass appeal for Fire Lieutenant, confirming the Commission's "broad remedial powers" in regard to the relief that was ordered by the Commission.
The Boston Police Department had just cause to terminate the Appellant as a police officer where his conduct was violative of the Boston Police Department’s Rules and Regulations based on three specific incidents involving misconduct.