Overview
The Pioneer Valley Transit Authority (PVTA) did not submit required financial information about its operations (e.g., expenditures) to the Executive Office for Administration and Finance (EOAF) so this information could be made available to the public on a searchable website. Therefore, PVTA did not allow the Commonwealth to give the public a sufficient level of transparency regarding PVTA’s operations, including its overall financial health and the nature and extent of its expenses.
Authoritative Guidance
Section 14C of Chapter 7 of the Massachusetts General Laws requires agencies, including quasi-public independent entities such as PVTA, to report their “appropriations, expenditures, grants, subgrants, loans, purchase orders, infrastructure assistance and other forms of financial assistance” to the Secretary of EOAF for inclusion on the Comptroller of the Commonwealth’s searchable website. Section 14C(e) states, “All agencies shall provide to the secretary all data that is required to be included in the searchable website not later than 30 days after the data becomes available to the agency.”
Reasons for Noncompliance
In its response to our draft report, PVTA senior management stated,
The RTAs as a group proposed a low cost alternative to their participation in this initiative, which involved publication of the financial data on the RTAs’ individual websites. Chapter 7, Section 14C under clause (g) contemplates and provides for the redirection of the public from the State's Open Checkbook website to other government websites as long as each of those websites complies with the requirements of this section.
PVTA has made a concerted effort over the years to comply with the spirit and transparency goal of the Chapter 7, Section 14C “Open Checkbook (CTHRU)” initiative through the publication of its payroll and financial payment information, audited financial statements, and approved fiscal year budgets on its website in a searchable format. We believe the financial information currently contained on our website provides the public with a sufficient level of transparency regarding PVTA'S operations, including its overall financial health and the nature and extent of its expenses. As a matter of routine, we direct public requests for PVTA’s financial information to the Open Government section of our website, which in most instances satisfies the public’s request for information. In those rare cases a request for information is not contained on our website, we treat it as a Public Information Request and quickly respond to the individual, generally at no cost.
Recommendations
- PVTA should develop formal policies and procedures for submitting this required information to EOAF.
- PVTA should establish monitoring controls to ensure that the staff members assigned to this task adhere to these policies and procedures
Auditee’s Response
PVTA with all other RTAs met with the State Comptroller’s Office on Tuesday June 12, 2018, to determine the best way to get the data quickly on the EOAF website, the first step taken was to immediately place the PVTA’s website URL for the open government data as a link. The next step to be taken is to work out the data submission time lines as the state offices have differing schedules of submission. PVTA will develop its policy and monitoring controls once the time lines and final delivery criteria have been agreed to with the State Comptroller’s Office. PVTA is committed to open government and transparency.
Auditor’s Reply
Based on its response, PVTA is taking measures to ensure that it reports this required information to EOAF.
| Date published: | January 30, 2019 |
|---|