- This page, BBRS Energy Advisory Committee Meeting - 9.14.26, is offered by
- Division of Occupational Licensure
- Office of Public Safety and Inspections
- Board of Building Regulations and Standards
Public Meeting Notice BBRS Energy Advisory Committee Meeting - 9.14.26
Overview
This is a remote meeting. You can participate from your computer, laptop, or smartphone.
You will need
Microsoft Teams meeting link and dial-in number
Meeting ID: 257 011 829 511 993
Passcode: Ni6ha3SB
Dial in by phone
+1 857-327-9245,,702992670# United States, Boston
Phone conference ID: 702 992 670#
In accordance with the provisions of G.L. c. 30A § 20, notice is hereby given that the Board of Building Regulations and Standards 11th Edition Energy Advisory Subcommittee will be convening a regular meeting.
If you need reasonable accommodation to participate in the meeting, please reach out to Cheryl Yebba at 617- 701-8711. The Agency will make best efforts to accommodate requests received in a timely manner.
Meeting Minutes
In accordance with the provisions of G.L. c. 30A § 20, the Board of Building Regulations and Standards Energy Advisory Committee convened a regular monthly meeting on:
Microsoft Teams Meeting September 14th, 2026
The topics shown below were discussed at the aforementioned meeting: 10:01 AM Chair Ian Finlayson called the open meeting to order.
Informational note: All votes were taken by roll call. Where each member voted in favor, the vote will be reported as unanimous.
Committee Members Present:
- Ian Finlayson - Chair
- Rebecca Ansolabehere
- Michael Browne
- Nathan Darling
- Tarica Leskiw
- Paulette McGhie
- Rebecca Rahmlow
- Brianna Skowyra (joined at 10:09 AM)
Committee Members Absent:
- Vineet Nair
DOL Members Present:
- Tammy Gropman, Executive Director
- Charles Kilb, Senior Board Counsel
Acknowledged Public Attendees:
- Shilpa Surana
- Becca Edson
- Sarah Newman
- Reviewed, Discussed, and Voted Minutes of the following Energy Advisory Meetings:
- August 24th, 2026 – It was noted that the meeting minutes will need to be approved at the next meeting, no action taken.
- Reviewed, Discussed, and Voted Code Change Proposal Forms and Front-End Amendments
- IECC 2024 Commercial Chapter 6
- Members reviewed the proposed amendments to Chapter 6, Reference Standards. The discussion focused on carrying forward the newer reference standards from the IECC 2027 public comment draft while retaining the 2024 ICC standards for the code cycle being adopted. Members reviewed the revised presentation of the standards, including changes in publication dates and the removal of references to codes not adopted in Massachusetts. It was noted that the explanatory table showing changes between the 2024 and 2027 standards was intended for navigation during the review process and would be removed from the final version.
- Ian Finlayson motioned to adopt Chapter 6 as amended, seconded by Michael Browne. A roll call vote was held, none opposed, none abstained. Motion passed unanimously.
- Ian Finlayson motioned to approve Chapter 6 Code Change Proposal form, seconded by Michael Browne. A roll call vote was held, none opposed, none abstained. Motion passed unanimously.
- Ian Finlayson motioned to adopt Chapter 6 as amended, seconded by Michael Browne. A roll call vote was held, none opposed, none abstained. Motion passed unanimously.
- Members reviewed the proposed amendments to Chapter 6, Reference Standards. The discussion focused on carrying forward the newer reference standards from the IECC 2027 public comment draft while retaining the 2024 ICC standards for the code cycle being adopted. Members reviewed the revised presentation of the standards, including changes in publication dates and the removal of references to codes not adopted in Massachusetts. It was noted that the explanatory table showing changes between the 2024 and 2027 standards was intended for navigation during the review process and would be removed from the final version.
- IECC 2024 Commercial Chapter 2
- Members reviewed proposed changes to the definitions in Chapter 2. Discussion included the electric vehicle and electric vehicle supply equipment definitions being carried forward from the 10th edition and the use of related definitions associated with EV-ready provisions. Members also discussed whether an informational note referencing 527 CMR should remain in the code. Legal counsel explained that other subcommittees would use such notes for the benefit of users as they indicate areas that are not governed by the building code. Members in discussion also noted that the note was unnecessary because the Massachusetts code would itself contain the applicable requirements, and retaining the reference could create confusion if 527 CMR definitions changed independently. The note was therefore removed from the draft by unanimous consent.
- Members also reviewed revised definitions for enthalpy recovery ratio, sensible recovery efficiency, and total recovery efficiency, with the intent of maintaining consistency with the Massachusetts stretch code; definitions related to renewable energy provisions that were no longer needed because of changes to Section 405 were identified for deletion.
- Michael Browne motioned to adopt Chapter 2 as amended, seconded by Paulette McGhie. A roll call vote was held, none opposed, none abstained. Motion passed unanimously.
- Michael Browne motioned to approve Chapter 2 Code Change Proposal form, seconded by Ian Finlayson. A roll call vote was held, none opposed, none abstained. Motion passed unanimously.
- Michael Browne motioned to adopt Chapter 2 as amended, seconded by Paulette McGhie. A roll call vote was held, none opposed, none abstained. Motion passed unanimously.
- Members also reviewed revised definitions for enthalpy recovery ratio, sensible recovery efficiency, and total recovery efficiency, with the intent of maintaining consistency with the Massachusetts stretch code; definitions related to renewable energy provisions that were no longer needed because of changes to Section 405 were identified for deletion.
- Members reviewed proposed changes to the definitions in Chapter 2. Discussion included the electric vehicle and electric vehicle supply equipment definitions being carried forward from the 10th edition and the use of related definitions associated with EV-ready provisions. Members also discussed whether an informational note referencing 527 CMR should remain in the code. Legal counsel explained that other subcommittees would use such notes for the benefit of users as they indicate areas that are not governed by the building code. Members in discussion also noted that the note was unnecessary because the Massachusetts code would itself contain the applicable requirements, and retaining the reference could create confusion if 527 CMR definitions changed independently. The note was therefore removed from the draft by unanimous consent.
- IECC 2024 Commercial Chapter 6
- Reviewed, Discussed, Voted Code Change Proposal Forms
- F. Nagle – Enclosed Parking Garages 780 CMR 101.4.2
- Members reviewed the enclosed parking garage proposal concerning 780 CMR 101.4.2 and discussed the proposed ventilation and control strategy in detail. The proposal would add language to IMC 404.3 requiring a minimum ventilation rate of 0.15 cfm per square foot during garage operating hours, together with fan modulation based on real-time gas sensor readings.
- Members discussed the relationship between the proposal and the 2024 IECC parking garage ventilation controls, which presently allow ventilation airflow to be reduced to 0.05 cfm per square foot of floor area served and not more than 20 percent of assigned capacity. Discussion focused on whether the existing 0.05 cfm rate adequately addresses stack effect, particularly in below-grade and high-rise garages, and whether the proposed 0.15 cfm minimum would better maintain negative-to-neutral pressure relative to occupied portions of a building.
- Members raised concerns about the extent to which garage air leakage and building pressure relationships are known or measured, noting that garage tightness could materially affect the pressure conditions being discussed.
- Members also discussed the proposed control strategy, including linear demand control ventilation (DCV), standard variable flow, and on-off sensor systems. The discussion addressed the potential for continuous low-level ventilation to reduce the need for higher fan speeds, improve energy efficiency, and reduce peak electrical demand. Members further discussed sensor reliability and the need for controls to respond appropriately to sensor failure rather than allowing a failed sensor to result in insufficient ventilation.
- The proposal was characterized as seeking both an increase in the minimum ventilation rate from 0.05 to 0.15 cfm per square foot and revisions to the control strategy, while potentially allowing either linear DCV or standard variable flow if adequate sensor-failure protections were included. Members also considered the relationship to ASHRAE 62.1 and 90.1, including the existing continuous-ventilation provisions in ASHRAE 62.1 and the potential for future revisions to ASHRAE 90.1.
- Members concluded that the proposal was not yet in a form suitable for a vote and that additional work was needed to translate the concepts into Massachusetts-specific amendments to the IMC and IECC. Members discussed DOER potentially working with the proposer to develop coordinated Massachusetts language, including the 0.05-to-0.15 cfm per square foot change, the allowable control strategies, and sensor-failure provisions.
- The proposal was characterized as seeking both an increase in the minimum ventilation rate from 0.05 to 0.15 cfm per square foot and revisions to the control strategy, while potentially allowing either linear DCV or standard variable flow if adequate sensor-failure protections were included. Members also considered the relationship to ASHRAE 62.1 and 90.1, including the existing continuous-ventilation provisions in ASHRAE 62.1 and the potential for future revisions to ASHRAE 90.1.
- Members also discussed the proposed control strategy, including linear demand control ventilation (DCV), standard variable flow, and on-off sensor systems. The discussion addressed the potential for continuous low-level ventilation to reduce the need for higher fan speeds, improve energy efficiency, and reduce peak electrical demand. Members further discussed sensor reliability and the need for controls to respond appropriately to sensor failure rather than allowing a failed sensor to result in insufficient ventilation.
- Members raised concerns about the extent to which garage air leakage and building pressure relationships are known or measured, noting that garage tightness could materially affect the pressure conditions being discussed.
- Members discussed the relationship between the proposal and the 2024 IECC parking garage ventilation controls, which presently allow ventilation airflow to be reduced to 0.05 cfm per square foot of floor area served and not more than 20 percent of assigned capacity. Discussion focused on whether the existing 0.05 cfm rate adequately addresses stack effect, particularly in below-grade and high-rise garages, and whether the proposed 0.15 cfm minimum would better maintain negative-to-neutral pressure relative to occupied portions of a building.
- Members reviewed the enclosed parking garage proposal concerning 780 CMR 101.4.2 and discussed the proposed ventilation and control strategy in detail. The proposal would add language to IMC 404.3 requiring a minimum ventilation rate of 0.15 cfm per square foot during garage operating hours, together with fan modulation based on real-time gas sensor readings.
- F. Nagle – Enclosed Parking Garages 780 CMR 101.4.2
- Reviewed, Discussed, and Voted 2024 IRC Appendices
- ND, NE, NG, NH, NI, NK, NL - Members reviewed appendices regarding energy storage systems, electric vehicle charging infrastructure, IECC stretch code provisions, operational carbon rating and energy reporting, on-site renewable energy and off-site alternatives, electric-ready residential building provisions Renewable Energy Infrastructure. Ian Finlayson motioned to not adopt Appendices ND, NE, NG, NH, NI, NK, NL, seconded by Nate Darling. A roll call vote was held, none opposed, none abstained. Motion passed unanimously.
- NF – Members discussed Appendix NF as an alternative prescriptive method for achieving required insulation R-values or U-factors, including additional continuous-insulation options for wood-framed walls, basements, and crawl spaces. The appendix was viewed as providing useful flexibility for projects that want to use less typical insulation configurations, while allowing compliance through lookup tables rather than separate calculations. Members discussed incorporating the appendix into the IECC Section 402.1.3 prescriptive table through a footnote directing users to Appendix NF. The group was informed that the adoption language would be brought back in code change proposal form at a future meeting, requiring reopening the previously approved Section 402 provisions.
- NJ – Members reviewed Appendix NJ, which addresses demand response controls for residential electric storage water heaters, including equipment up to 120 gallons and controls complying with AHRI 1430 or the ANSI equivalent. Members discussed the potential value of adopting the provision in the base code, particularly because Massachusetts was considering appliance standards that could require demand response capability on new water heating equipment. Members also discussed potential amendments to recognize both utility demand-response signals and time-of-use controls.
- Discuss Matters Not Reasonably Anticipated 48 Hours in Advance of the Meeting
- Members discussed future meeting dates. A member of the public, Sarah Newman, raised a Chapter 4 question regarding shading options, the chair indicated that the concerns were legitimate and would be addressed at a future meeting.
- Adjournment – The next meeting will be held on September 28th, 2026.
- Rebecca Ansolabehere motioned to adjourn the meeting, seconded by Tarica Leskiw. A roll call vote was held, none opposed, none abstained. Motion passed unanimously.
- Meeting adjourned at 11:54 AM.
Items Relied Upon
Meeting Agenda
Draft Meeting Minutes
2024 IECC
2024 IRC
Code Change Proposals
Applicable provisions of 780 CMR
Agenda
| Members |
|---|
| Ian Finlayson |
| Rebecca Ansolabehere |
| Michael Browne |
| Nathan Darling |
| Tarica Leskiw |
| Paulette McGhie |
| Vineet Nair |
| Rebecca Rahmlow |
| Brianna Skowyra |
It is anticipated that the topics shown below will be discussed at the aforementioned meeting:
- Review/Discuss/Vote Minutes of the following Energy Advisory Meetings:
- August 24, 2026
- Review/Discuss/ Vote Code Change Proposal Forms and Front-End Amendments
- IECC 2024 Commercial Chapter 6
- IECC 2024 Commercial Chapter 2
- Review/Discuss/Vote Code Change Proposal Forms
- F. Nagle – Enclosed Parking Garages 780 CMR 101.4.2
- Review/Discuss/Vote 2024 IRC Appendices
- ND
- NE
- NF
- NG
- NH
- NI
- NJ
- NK
- NL
- Discuss matters not reasonably anticipated by the chair, 48 hours in advance of the meeting