Massachusetts State Seal An official website of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Here's how you know

Official websites use .mass.gov

A .mass.gov website belongs to an official government organization in Massachusetts.

Secure websites use HTTPS

A lock icon or https:// means you've safely connected to the official website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Public Meeting Notice

Public Meeting Notice  Board of Registration of Real Estate Appraisers Meeting - 6.4.26

Meeting start time: 10:00am
Posted: May 28, 2026 3:23 p.m.

Overview

This is a remote meeting. You can participate from your computer, laptop, or smartphone. See the Meeting Agenda for details.

You will need

Microsoft Teams meeting link

Meeting ID: 254 488 073 084 4 

Passcode: Ea37D4G3

Download TeamsJoin on the web

Dial in to the meeting 

Meeting phone number:+18573279245United States, Boston 

Find a local number 

Phone conference ID: 608 955 007# 

In accordance with the provisions of G.L. c. 30A § 20, notice is hereby given that the Board of Real Estate Appraisers will convene a regular meeting.

If you need reasonable accommodation to participate in the meeting please reach out to Cheryl Yebba at 617- 701-8711. The Agency will make best efforts to accommodate requests received in a timely manner.

Meeting Minutes

In accordance with the provisions of G.L. c. 30A § 20, the Board of Real Estate Appraisers convened a regular monthly meeting on: 

Microsoft Teams Meeting June 4, 2026

The topics shown below were discussed at the aforementioned meeting: 10:02 A.M. the Chair T. Kokoliadis called the open meeting to order. 

Informational note: All votes were taken by roll call. Where each member voted in favor, the vote will be reported as unanimous.

Board members present: 

  • Thomas Kokoliadis, Chair, Certified Residential Appraiser/ Banking Member
  • Paula Wolfe, Vice Chair, Certified Residential Appraiser Member
  • Kenneth Dicks, Certified General Appraiser Member 
  • Matthew Jenkins, AMC Member 
  • William McLaughlin, Certified General Appraiser Member
  • Danyl Collings, Certified Residential Appraiser Member
  • Paul Yorkis, Real Estate Broker Member

Board members absent: 

DOL Staff present: 

  • Kristin Mitchell, Executive Director 
  • Stephen Pleva, Board Counsel

Acknowledged public attendees: 

  1. ReviewedApril 2, 2026, meeting minutes.
    1. M. Jenkins made a motion, and it was seconded by W. McLaughlin, and the members present by majority VOTED: to accept the minutes as written.
    2. Motion Passed - Roll Call:
MemberAyeNayRecusedAbstainedAbsent
T. KokoliadisX    
 P. Wolfe  X  
 K. DicksX    
M. JenkinsX    
   W. McLaughlinX    
D. CollingsX    
P. YorkisX    
  1. Executive Director and Board Counsel Reports:
    1. Executive Director Reported - Since the last meeting there were 27 new licenses and permits issued. Also updates on the new eLIPSE system
    2. Legal Counsel reported –Board Counsel updated the board on the status of the regulation review
  2. License Application Interview: Nothing to Report
  3. License Application Report and Votes
NameApplication TypeDecision
Cameron MitchellCertified Residential ExamApproved

P. Wolfe made a motion, and it was seconded by P. Yorkis, and the members present by majority VOTED: to allow applicant to move forward with the process.

Motion Passed - Roll Call:

MemberAyeNayRecusedAbstainedAbsent
T. KokoliadisX    
 P. WolfeX    
 K. DicksX    
M. JenkinsX    
   W. McLaughlinX    
D. CollingsX    
P. YorkisX    
NameApplication TypeDecision
Christopher ChoCertified Residential ExamApproved

D. Collings made a motion, and it was seconded by P. Wolfe, and the members present by majority VOTED: to allow applicant to move forward with the process.

Motion Passed - Roll Call:

MemberAyeNayRecusedAbstainedAbsent
T. KokoliadisX    
 P. WolfeX    
 K. DicksX    
M. JenkinsX    
   W. McLaughlinX    
D. CollingsX    
P. YorkisX    
NameApplication TypeDecision
Jonathan LoweCertified General ExamApproved

K. Dicks made a motion, and it was seconded by W. McLaughlin, and the members present by majority VOTED: to allow applicant to move forward with the process.

Motion Passed - Roll Call:

MemberAyeNayRecusedAbstainedAbsent
T. KokoliadisX    
 P. WolfeX    
 K. DicksX    
M. JenkinsX    
   W. McLaughlinX    
D. CollingsX    
P. YorkisX    
NameApplication TypeDecision
Ryan AndersonCertified General ExamApproved

The Board discussed that many of the appraisals were completed in other states in which the applicant does not hold a trainee license.  The chair recognized the applicant who explained that his supervising appraisers held licenses in all states.  The applicant noted that although his application only identifies one supervisor he can provide additional information from another supervisor in his work log and affidavits.  P. Yorkis made a motion, and it was seconded by K. Dicks, and the members present by majority VOTED: to allow applicant to move forward with the process upon receipt of updated work log and corrected affidavit form.

Motion Passed - Roll Call:

MemberAyeNayRecusedAbstainedAbsent
T. KokoliadisX    
 P. WolfeX    
 K. DicksX    
M. JenkinsX    
   W. McLaughlinX    
D. CollingsX    
P. YorkisX    
NameApplication TypeDecision
Megan BalchCertified General ExamDenied

The Board discussed that the applicant did not identify a supervisor in her work log or provide a supervisor attestation. In communication with the Board, the applicant claimed she did not need a supervisor but identified one of the certified general appraisers who provided minimal oversight.  The Board noted that the person identified was unable to act as a supervisor due to previous discipline and that they are unable to credit the work experience provided. K. Dicks made a motion, and it was seconded by P. Wolfe, and the members present by majority VOTED: to deny the application.

Motion Passed - Roll Call:

MemberAyeNayRecusedAbstainedAbsent
T. KokoliadisX    
 P. WolfeX    
 K. DicksX    
M. JenkinsX    
   W. McLaughlinX    
D. CollingsX    
P. YorkisX    
  1. Education Report and Votes:

    P. Wolfe made a motion, and it was seconded by D. Collings, and the members present by majority VOTED: to accept reviewers’ decision on the education below.

    Motion Passed - Roll Call:

MemberAyeNayRecusedAbstainedAbsent
T. KokoliadisX    
 P. WolfeX    
 K. DicksX    
M. JenkinsX    
   W. McLaughlinX    
D. CollingsX    
P. YorkisX    
Provider NameCourse NameHoursTypeResFlagAQBOnlineRecommendation
ASFMRA
Mastering the Consultant and Expert Witness Role
8CENR/ENoNoBoard Approved
MBREAEnhancing Appraisal Efficiency, Insight, and Compliance with Artificial Intelligence3CENR/RNoNoBoard Approved
Green Mountain eLearningValuation Bias and Fair Housing Laws and Regulations7CENR/R/EYesYesStaff Approved
MA Chapter of IAAOWorkshop 452 - Fundamentals of Assessment Ratio Studies16CENR/RNoNoBoard Approved
Appraisal InstituteOnline Subdivision Valuation7CENRYesYesStaff Approved
Appraisal InstituteGeneral Appraiser Report Writing and Case Studies30QENRYesYesStaff Approved
Appraisal InstituteOnline General Appraiser Report Writing and Case Studies28CENRYesYesStaff Approved
University of UtahMastering Conservation Easement Appraisals: Think Like the IRS7CENRNoNoBoard Approved
Appraisal Institute
Appraisal of Medical Office Buildings
7CENRYesYesStaff Approved
Appraisal Institute15-Hour Equivalent USPAP Course15QEUSPAPYesYesStaff Approved
Appraiser eLearning, LLC2026 Val Expo - Day 17CENR/R/ENoNoBoard Approved
Appraiser eLearning, LLC2026 Val Expo - Day 27CENR/R/ENoNoBoard Approved
Green Mountain eLearningAppraisal Review Essentials: Developing Competency with Standards 3 and 47.3CENR/R/ENoYesStaff Approved
The CE Shop, LLCBarndos to Domes: Appraising Unconventional Homes3CERYesYesStaff Approved
  1. Board Discussion and Votes: Nothing to Report
  2.  Discussedother matters not reasonably anticipated 48 hours in advance of the meeting: Chair Kokoliadis asked Executive Director Mitchell to add the topic of AARO under discussion for the next meeting.
  3. Executive Session, CLOSED per M.G.L. c. 30A, sec. 21(a)(1): Nothing to Report
  4. Quasi-Judicial Session CLOSED Per M.G.L. c. 30A, § 18(D) : Nothing to Report
  5.  Investigative Conference (M.G.L. c. 112, § 65C – Closed session)

D. Collings made a motion, and it was seconded by P. Yorkis, and the members present by majority VOTED: to exit the Open Meeting and enter Closed Investigative Conference under M.G.L. c. 112, s. 65C.

Motion Passed - Roll Call:

MemberAyeNayRecusedAbstainedAbsent
T. KokoliadisX    
 P. WolfeX    
 K. DicksX    
M. JenkinsX    
   W. McLaughlinX    
D. CollingsX    
P. YorkisX    
  1. Discussion of the terms of negotiated settlement of complaint(s).
    1. Nothing to Report
  2. Discussion of complaints prior to the issuance of an order to show cause
    1. 00029513 ~Forwarded to Prosecutions
    2. 00035014 ~ Dismissed with Advisory; D. Collings recused
  3. Adjournment – the next meeting is scheduled for July 2, 2026, at 10 A.M.

K. Dicks made a motion, P. Yorkis seconded, and the members present unanimously,

VOTED: to exit Investigative Conference and enter open session, thereupon to adjourn the meeting at 11:53 A.M.

MemberAyeNayRecused/AbstainedAbsent
T. KokoliadisX   
 P. WolfeX   
 K. DicksX   
M. JenkinsX   
   W. McLaughlinX   
D. Collings   X
P. YorkisX   

Items relied upon during the open meeting

  • Agenda
  • Draft minutes April 2, 2026
  • Reports for: Cameron Mitchell, Christopher Cho, Jonathan Lowe, Ryan Anderson, and Meg Balch
  • Application for: Megan Balch

Agenda

It is anticipated that the topics shown below will be discussed at the aforementioned meeting: 

  1. Open Meeting
  2. Review and Vote onMinutes of the following meetings: 
    1. Open Session Minutes April 2, 2026
  3. Review/Discuss Reports:
    1. Executive Director
      1. eLIPSE Transition
    2. Legal Counsel
  4. License Application Interview: Reserved if Needed
  5. License Application Report and Votes:
NameApplication Type
Cameron MitchellCertified Residential Exam
Christopher ChoCertified Residential Exam
Jonathan LoweCertified General Exam
Ryan AndersonCertified General Exam
Megan BalchCertified General Exam
  1. Education Report and Votes:
Provider NameCourse NameHoursTypeResFlagAQBOnlineRecommendation
ASFMRA
Mastering the Consultant and Expert Witness Role
8CENR/ENoNoBoard Review
MBREAEnhancing Appraisal Efficiency, Insight, and Compliance with Artificial Intelligence3CENR/RNoNoBoard Review
Green Mountain eLearningValuation Bias and Fair Housing Laws and Regulations7CENR/R/EYesYesStaff Approved
MA Chapter of IAAOWorkshop 452 - Fundamentals of Assessment Ratio Studies16CENR/RNoNoBoard Review
Appraisal InstituteOnline Subdivision Valuation7CENRYesYesStaff Approved
Appraisal InstituteGeneral Appraiser Report Writing and Case Studies30QENRYesYesStaff Approved
Appraisal InstituteOnline General Appraiser Report Writing and Case Studies28CENRYesYesStaff Approved
University of UtahMastering Conservation Easement Appraisals: Think Like the IRS7CENRNoNoBoard Review
Appraisal Institute
Appraisal of Medical Office Buildings
7CENRYesYesStaff Approved
Appraisal Institute15-Hour Equivalent USPAP Course15QEUSPAPYesYesStaff Approved
Appraiser eLearning, LLC2026 Val Expo - Day 17CENR/R/ENoNoBoard Review
Appraiser eLearning, LLC2026 Val Expo - Day 27CENR/R/ENoNoBoard Review
Green Mountain eLearningAppraisal Review Essentials: Developing Competency with Standards 3 and 47.3CENR/R/ENoYesStaff Approved
The CE Shop, LLCBarndos to Domes: Appraising Unconventional Homes3CERYesYesStaff Approved
  1. Items for Discussion and/or Action: Reserved if Needed
  2. Discuss matters not reasonably anticipated by the chair, 48 hours in advance of the meeting
  3. Executive Session (Closed Session): Reserved if Needed
    1. To discuss the reputation, character, physical condition or mental health, rather than professional competence, of an individual (M.G.L. c. 30A, § 21(a)(1)) and/or to comply with the public records law pursuant to G.L. c. 66, § 10 and G.L. c. 4, § 7, ¶ 26(c) to protect highly personal information relating to a named individual (M.G.L. c. 30A, § 21(a)(7))
  4. Quasi-Judicial: Closed session, adjudicatory conference pursuant to G. L. c. 30A, § 18, ¶ 5(d).  ~ Reserved if Necessary
  5. Closed session (M.G.L. c. 112, § 65C –Investigative conferences and settlement conferences)
    1. Discussion of terms of a negotiated settlement of complaint case:
    2. Discussion of complaints prior to the issuance of an order to show cause

Adjournment – the next scheduled meeting is July 2, 2026

Help Us Improve Mass.gov  with your feedback

Please do not include personal or contact information.
Feedback