- This page, Board of Registration of Real Estate Appraisers Meeting - 8.18.25, is offered by
- Division of Occupational Licensure
- Board of Registration of Real Estate Appraisers
Public Meeting Notice Board of Registration of Real Estate Appraisers Meeting - 8.18.25
Overview
This is a remote meeting. You can participate from your computer, laptop, or smartphone. See the Meeting Agenda for details.
Meeting Minutes
Members Present:
Michael Giannelli, Chair, Certified Residential Appraiser Member
Thomas Kokoliadis, Vice Chair, Banking Member
Kenneth Dicks, Certified General Appraiser Member
Matthew Jenkins, AMC Member
Paul Yorkis, Real Estate Broker Member
Paula Wolfe, Certified Residential Appraiser Member
William McLaughlin, Certified General Appraiser Member
Members Not Present:
Timothy McDonough, State Licensed Appraiser/Municipal Assessor
Administrative Staff Present:
Kristin Mitchell, Executive Director
Lynn Read, Board Counsel
Board members, staff, and members of the public appeared by video conference.
- Call to Order – Board Chair Michael Giannelli opened the meeting at 10:05 a.m.
- Vote on Minutes of Open Meeting of July 10, 2025 and Executive Session of May 8, 2025–. A MOTION was made by Mr. Yorkis to table the draft open minutes of July 10, 2025 and executive session minutes meeting held May 8, 2025. The Motion was seconded by Ms. Wolfe and unanimously adopted by a roll call vote: Giannelli – “Yes;” Kokoliadis - “Yes”; McLaughlin - “Yes”; Jenkins – “Yes”; Dicks – “Yes”; Wolfe – “Yes; Yorkis – “Yes.”
- DOL Report of Executive Director and Board Counsel: Kristin Mitchell reported to the Board that there were 23 licenses/permits issued since the last meeting. Lynn Read updated on the status of the draft amended regulations.
- Education Report: A MOTION was made by Mr. Kokoliadis to ratify reviewers’ decisions for Education applications. The Motion was seconded by Ms. Wolfe and unanimously adopted by a roll call vote: : Giannelli – “Yes;” Kokoliadis - “Yes”; McLaughlin - “Yes”; Jenkins – “Yes”; Dicks – “Yes”; Wolfe – “Yes; Yorkis – “Yes.”
Provider Name | Course Name | Hours | Type | ResFlag | AQB | Online | Recommendations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Appraisal Institute | Residential Report Writing and Case Studies | 15 | QE | R | Yes | Yes | Staff Approved |
| Trusted Advisors GAP Services, LL | Valuation Bias and Fair Housing Laws | 8 | CE | R/NR | Yes | Yes | Staff Approved |
| MBREA | 2025 New England Appraisers Expo Residential Program | 3 | CE | R/NR | No | No | Board Approved |
| MBREA | Massachusetts ADUs: Navigating New Regulations, Valuation & Lending Implications | 2 | CE | R/NR | No | No | Board Approved |
| MBREA | 2025 New England Appraiser Expo Commercial Program | 3 | CE | R/NR | No | No | Board Approved |
| MBREA | 2025 New England Appraiser Expo General Session | 4 | CE | R/NR | No | No | Board Approved |
| The CE Shop | Valuation Bias and Fair Housing Laws and Regulations | 8 | QE | R/NR | Yes | Yes | Staff Approved |
| Appraisal Institute | Online Understanding and Appraising Residential REOs | 4 | CE | R | Yes | Yes | Staff Approved |
| The CE Shop | Valuation Bias and Fair Housing Laws and Regulations | 7 | CE | R/NR | Yes | Yes | Staff Approved |
| Massachusetts Association of Assessing Officers | 2024-2025 15-Hour USPAP Update Course | 15 | QE | USPAP | Yes | No | Staff Approved |
| Massachusetts Association of Assessing Officers | 2024-2025 7-Hour USPAP Update Course | 7 | CE | USPAP | Yes | No | Staff Approved |
| ASFMRA | Valuation Bias and Fair Housing Laws and Regulations (A112) | 7 | QE | R/NR | Yes | No | Staff Approved |
| ASFMRA | Valuation Bias and Fair Housing Laws and Regulations (A112) | 7 | CE | E | Yes | No | Staff Approved |
| ASFMRA | Rapid Fire Case Studies 2025 | 6 | CE | E | No | No | Board Approved |
| ASFMRA | ASFMRA Annual Meeting 2025 | 4 | CE | E | No | No | Board Approved |
| Appraisal Institute | Online Valuation Bias and Fair Housing Laws and Regulations | 7 | CE | R/NR | No | Yes | Staff Approved |
| Appraisal Institute | Online Appraiser’s Guide to the New URAR | 7 | CE | R/E | Yes | Yes | Staff Approved |
| Appraisal Institute | Online Valuation Bias and Fair Housing Laws and Regulations | 7 | QE | R/NR | No | Yes | Staff Approved |
- Board Discussion and Potential Votes: Nothing to Report
- Matters Not Reasonably Anticipated: Nothing to Report
- Executive Session (Closed Session) To discuss individuals’ character, rather than competence (M.G.L. c. 30A, § 21(a)(1)) and/or to comply with the public records law pursuant to G.L. c. 66, § 10 and G.L. c. 4, § 7, ¶ 26(c) to protect highly personal information relating to a named individual (M.G.L. c. 30A, § 21(a)(7): Reserved if needed, not needed.
- Quasi-Judicial Session CLOSED per M.G.L. c. 30A, § 18(d): Reserved if needed, not needed.
- Investigative Conference, Closed Session per M.G.L. c. 112, s. 65C: A MOTION was made at 10:13 a.m. by Mr. Yorkis to exit the public meeting and enter Closed Investigative Conference under M.G.L. c. 112, s. 65C. The Motion was seconded by Ms. Wolfe and unanimously adopted by the Board by a roll call vote: : Giannelli – “Yes;” Kokoliadis - “Yes”; McLaughlin - “Yes”; Jenkins – “Yes”; Dicks – “Yes”; Wolfe – “Yes; Yorkis – “Yes.”
The following actions were taken by the Board:
- Discussion of the terms of negotiated settlement of complaint(s): None
- Discussion of complaints prior to the issuance of an order to show cause:
- 2025-000305-IT-ENF: Dismissed with Advisory
- 2025-000879-IT-ENF: Dismissed
- Adjourn:
Mr. Yorkis made a MOTION to adjourn the meeting at 10:56 a.m., seconded by Mr. Kokoliadis and unanimously adopted by a roll call vote: Giannelli – “Yes;” Kokoliadis - “Yes”; McLaughlin - “Yes”; Jenkins – “Yes”; Dicks – “Yes”; Wolfe – “Yes; Yorkis – “Yes.”
The above Minutes were approved at the Open Meeting held October 9, 2025
List of Documents Used in Open Meeting:
Agenda for meeting of August 18, 2025
Course Applications Approved by the Board per above