Chalk: Requirements of proof for homicide

I.   MURDER IN THE FIRST DEGREE    

A. Murder with Deliberate Premeditation
  1. The defendant caused the death of [name of victim].
  2. The defendant intended to kill.
  3. The defendant committed the killing with deliberate premeditation.
  4. [Where there is evidence of self-defense or defense of another] The defendant did not act in proper self-defense or in the proper defense of another.
  5. [Where there is evidence of mitigating circumstances]  There were no mitigating circumstances.
B. Murder with Extreme Atrocity or Cruelty
  1. The defendant caused the death of [name of victim].
  2. The defendant either:
    1. intended to kill; or
    2. intended to cause grievous bodily harm; or
    3. intended to do an act which, in the circumstances known to him, a reasonable person would have known created a plain and strong likelihood that death would result.
  3. The killing was committed with extreme atrocity or cruelty.
  4. [Where there is evidence of self-defense or defense of another] The defendant did not act in proper self-defense or in the proper defense of another.
  5. [Where there is evidence of mitigating circumstances]  There were no mitigating circumstances.
C.   Felony-Murder
  1. The defendant committed or attempted to commit [name of crime], a felony with a maximum sentence of life imprisonment.
  2. The killing was caused by an act of the defendant [or a person participating with the defendant] in the commission or attempted commission of the underlying felony.
  3. The act that caused the killing occurred during the commission or attempted commission of the felony.          
  4. The defendant either:          
    1. intended to kill; or
    2. intended to cause grievous bodily harm; or 
    3. intended to do an act which, in the circumstances known to him, a reasonable person would have known created a plain and strong likelihood that death would result.
  5. [Where there is evidence of self-defense or defense of another] The defendant did not act in proper self-defense or in the proper defense of another.
  6. [Where there is evidence of mitigating circumstances] There were no mitigating circumstances. 

II.  MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE                                                            

A.   Murder
  1. The defendant caused the death of [name of victim].
  2. The defendant either:
    1. intended to kill; or 
    2. intended to cause grievous bodily harm; or
    3. intended to do an act which, in the circumstances known to him, a reasonable person would have known created a plain and strong likelihood that death would result.
  3. [Where there is evidence of self-defense or defense of another] The defendant did not act in proper self-defense or in the proper defense of another.
  4. [Where there is evidence of mitigating circumstances]  There were no mitigating circumstances.                            

III. VOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER

A.   Voluntary Manslaughter as a Lesser Included Offense
  1. The defendant caused the death of [name of victim].                                              
  2. The defendant either:
    1. intended to kill; or 
    2. intended to cause grievous bodily harm; or
    3. intended to do an act which, in the circumstances known to him, a reasonable person would have known created a plain and strong likelihood that death would result.
  3. [Where there is evidence of self-defense or defense of another] The defendant did not act in proper self-defense or in the proper defense of another.
B.  Voluntary Manslaughter Absent a Murder Charge
  1. The defendant intentionally inflicted an injury or injuries on [name of victim] likely to cause death.
  2. The defendant caused the death of [name of victim].
  3. [Where there is evidence of self-defense or defense of another]  The defendant did not act in proper self-defense or in the proper defense of another.

IV.  INVOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER

A.   Death Caused by Wanton or Reckless Conduct
  1. The defendant caused the death of [name of victim].
  2. The defendant intended the conduct that caused the death of [name of victim].
  3. The defendant's conduct was wanton or reckless.
  4. [Where there is evidence of self-defense or defense of another] The defendant did not act in proper self-defense or in the proper defense of another.
B.   Death Caused by Wanton or Reckless Failure to Act    
  1. There was a special relationship between the defendant and [name of victim] which gave rise to a duty of care, or the defendant created a situation that posed a grave risk of death or serious injury to another.
  2. The defendant's failure to act caused the death of [name of victim]. 
  3. The defendant intentionally failed to act.                             
  4. The defendant's failure to act was wanton or reckless.
C.   Death Unintentionally Caused by a Battery
  1. The defendant caused the death of [name of victim].
  2. The defendant intentionally committed a battery upon [name of victim] that endangered human life.
  3. The defendant knew or reasonably should have known that the battery endangered human life.
  4. [Where there is evidence of self-defense or defense of another] The defendant did not act in proper self-defense or in the proper defense of another.

Additional Resources

Contact

Address

John Adams Courthouse
One Pemberton Square - 1M
Boston, MA 02108
Date published: April 25, 2018

Feedback

Did you find what you were looking for on this webpage? * required
We use your feedback to help us improve this site but we are not able to respond directly. Please do not include personal or contact information. If you need a response, please locate the contact information elsewhere on this page or in the footer.
We use your feedback to help us improve this site but we are not able to respond directly. Please do not include personal or contact information. If you need a response, please locate the contact information elsewhere on this page or in the footer.

If you need to report child abuse, any other kind of abuse, or need urgent assistance, please click here.

Feedback