Massachusetts State Seal An official website of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts Here's how you know

Official websites use .mass.gov

A .mass.gov website belongs to an official government organization in Massachusetts.

Secure websites use HTTPS

A lock icon or https:// means you've safely connected to the official website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Tax Expenditure Review Commission Meeting Minutes, June 12, 2026

Tax Expenditure Review Commission Meeting held on Friday, June 12, 2026, 11:00 am Via Zoom

Tax Expenditure Review Commission Meeting 
Friday, June 12, 2026
11:00 AM
Via Zoom

Commission Members in Attendance:

  • Chairperson Rebecca Forter, Designee, MA Department of Revenue
  • Lindsay Janeczek, Designee, MA Auditor
  • Senator James B. Eldridge, Senate Chair Joint Committee on Revenue
  • Thomas Baranowski, Designee, House Chair Joint Committee on Revenue
  • Andrew DeFalco, Designee, Senate Committee on Ways and Means
  • Chris Carlozzi, Designee, Senate Minority Leader
  • Jamie Oppedisano, Designee, House Minority Leader
  • Professor Natasha Varyani, Member, Governor’s Appointee
  • Professor Thomas Downes, Member, Governor’s Appointee

Commission Members Absent:

  • Representative Aaron Michlewitz, Member, House Ways and Means Committee
  • Sue Perez, Designee, MA Treasurer

Agenda Items:

  • Meeting Agenda
  • Draft Minutes
    • April 17, 2026 Meeting
  • Presentation of June tax expenditure evaluation ratings, discuss and vote on ratings
    • 1.108 & 2.102    Deferral of Federal Gain Invested in Qualified Opportunity Zones
    • 2.101     Deferral of Tax on Certain Shipping Companies
    • 2.205     Deduction for Certain Dividends of Cooperatives
    • 2.703     Exemption for Regulated Investment Companies
    • 3.108     Exemption for Certain Precious Metals
    • 3.109     Exemption for Cement Mixers
    • 1.611 & 2.614 & 3.004   Film Credit, Payroll and Production / Exemption for Sales to Motion Picture Production Companies

Meeting Minutes:

The meeting via teleconference was called to order at 11:03 AM.  Chairperson Forter welcomed Commission members, called roll, and a quorum was recognized.  Chairperson Forter noted that David Emer will no longer be serving the Commission as the designee for Senator James B. Eldridge, Senate Chair Joint Committee on Revenue, and thanked Senator Eldridge for joining today’s meeting.  Chairperson Forter put the Commission and public on notice that the meeting is recorded for the purpose of minutes.  The recording of the meeting will be kept for public record and will not be deleted. 

Chairperson Forter asked for any comments or questions on the April 17, 2026 meeting minutes.  Members did not provide any comment.  Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the minutes.  Tom Downes seconded the motion.  Jamie Oppedisano and Chris Carlozzi abstained since they were both absent from that meeting.  Members were in favor of approving the April ‘26 meeting minutes as drafted.  The meeting minutes will be posted to the TERC website.

Chairperson Forter and Lindsay Janeczek led a discussion on 1.108 and 2.102 Deferral of Federal Gain Invested in Qualified Opportunity Zones, which is a federal expenditure to which Massachusetts conforms.  Chairperson Forter noted that this is the first time this expenditure has been reviewed by the Commission.  Lindsay noted that this is a corporate excise and personal income tax expenditure.  Chairperson Forter noted that because the Massachusetts corporate excise conforms automatically to changes in the federal Code, this has been a corporate excise expenditure since the federal adoption in 2017, whereas it did not become a personal income tax expenditure until the chapter 62 Code conformity date was updated in 2022. Also, the personal income tax expenditure is set to expire December 31, 2026 because the Code as of January 1, 2024 (the current personal income tax conformity date) provided for that sunset. The federal sunset has since been repealed, which means that the Massachusetts corporate excise expenditure does not sunset.  The annual cost of the expenditure is $12.7 to $42.5 million per year from FY23 to FY26.  In FY 2027 there is an expected revenue gain of $90.8 million due to the expiration of the personal income deferral.  Taxpayers can elect to defer capital gain on the sale of assets if the gain is invested in a qualified opportunity zone.  The Commission assumes the goal of the expenditure is investment and access to opportunity.  The Commission voted “somewhat agree” on the questions of whether (i) we can measure the overall benefit toward achieving the goals, (ii) the tax expenditure’s benefit justify its fiscal cost, (iii) the tax expenditure is claimed by its intended beneficiaries, (iv) the amount claimed per taxpayer is meaningful as an incentive/benefit, and (v) the tax expenditure is relevant today.  The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the questions of whether (i) the tax expenditure is claimed by a broad group of taxpayers, (ii) the tax expenditure is easily administered, and (iii) the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to smaller businesses.  Lindsay noted that when the personal income tax expenditure expires it will complicate administration due to the difference in state and federal rules.  Chairperson Forter explained that the Supplemental Budget that is on the Governor’s desk for signature would limit the benefits to investments made in opportunity zones located in Massachusetts and that this divergence from the federal rules will somewhat complicate administration of the expenditure.  Tom Downes talked about two publications on opportunity zones that suggest that these investments would have occurred in absence of this tax expenditure and suggested that decoupling from this federal expenditure may make sense.  Natasha Varyani agreed with Tom’s point but suggested not flagging this expenditure for legislative review highlighting that the legislature has been looking at this topic in recent months.  She suggested it may be worthwhile to take a closer look during the next evaluation of this expenditure.  Tom Downes suggested moving the rating on the question of whether the tax expenditure’s benefit justifies its fiscal cost from “somewhat agree” to “somewhat disagree” due to the lack of evidence that this expenditure spurs investment.  Natasha and Chairperson Forter agreed with this change and suggested adding an additional comment to the evaluation template stating that the Commission has concerns about the lack of evidence showing that this expenditure is accomplishing its intended goals.  Tom noted that he will forward the citations to be included with the evaluation template.  The Commission agreed that this expenditure should not be flagged for legislative review.  Chairperson Forter asked if members had any questions.  No questions from members.  Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the evaluation template.  Tom seconded.  The Commission voted to approve the evaluation template for 1.108 and 2.102 Deferral of Federal Gain Invested in Qualified Opportunity Zones with these changes.

Jamie Oppedisano led a discussion on 2.101 Deferral of Tax on Certain Shipping Companies.  This tax expenditure was adopted in 1987 and has an annual revenue impact of $0.8 million with no sunset date.  This tax expenditure is a result of state conformity to the federal code.  The Code allows a deduction for contributions out of current income to merchant marine capital construction funds.  Amounts withdrawn from such funds are excluded from income if used for the acquisition, construction, modernization, or major repair of ships used in trade or fishing.  The Commission assumes the goal of the expenditure is job maintenance and creation, investment, competitiveness/strategic, and to simplify administration.  Jamie noted that in 2023 there was an expansion of this expenditure that permits additional companies to benefit including those offering sightseeing, harbor service operators and more.   Every state with a corporate income tax based on federal taxable income would allow the deduction unless the state specifically decouples from the deduction.  The Commission is not aware of any state that has decoupled.  The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the questions of whether (i) we can measure the overall benefit toward achieving the goals, (ii) the tax expenditure is claimed by a broad group, (iii) the amount claimed per taxpayer is meaningful as an incentive/benefit, and (iv) the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to smaller businesses.  Jamie noted that while some smaller businesses are benefitting from this expenditure, most of the benefits are claimed by larger businesses.  The Commission voted “somewhat agree” on the questions of whether (i) the tax expenditure’s benefit justifies its fiscal cost, (ii) the tax expenditure is claimed by its intended beneficiaries, and (iii) the tax expenditure is relevant today.  The Commission voted “strongly agree” on the question of whether the tax expenditure is easily administered.  The Commission agreed that this tax expenditure should not be flagged for legislative review.  Jamie asked where there were any questions.  No questions from members.  Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the evaluation template.  Jamie seconded the motion.  The Commission voted to approve the evaluation template for 2.101 Deferral of Tax on Certain Shipping Companies as presented.

Tom Downes led a discussion on 2.205 Deduction for Certain Dividends of Cooperatives.  Tom noted the relatively low cost of this expenditure, $0.6 to $0.7 million per year from FY23 to FY27, and that it is a result of conformity to the federal code.  The Commission assumes the goal of the expenditure is to encourage businesses to band together to take advantage of economies of scale when buying supplies or selling products.  The tax expenditure also prevents double taxation of patronage dividends.  Tom noted that it wouldn’t make sense to decouple from the federal code given the low annual cost of the deduction.  Tom noted that it is difficult to obtain information on the number of cooperatives operating in the Commonwealth.  The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the question of whether we can measure the overall benefit toward achieving the goals.  The Commission voted “strongly agree” on he questions of whether (i) the tax expenditure is claimed by its intended beneficiaries, (ii) the tax expenditure is relevant today, (iii) and the tax expenditure is easily administered.  The Commission voted “somewhat agree” on the question of whether the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to smaller businesses.  Tom noted that one of the agricultural businesses that claims this deduction is Ocean Spray, which is not a small business, but that most other claimants appear to be smaller businesses.  Chairperson Forter agreed that this tax expenditure should not be flagged for legislative review.  Tom asked if members had any questions.  No questions from members.  Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the evaluation template.  Tom seconded the motion.  The Commission voted to approve the evaluation template for 2.205 Deduction for Certain Dividends of Cooperatives as presented.

Natasha Varyani led a discussion on 2.703 Exemption for Regulated Investment Companies.  The annual cost of this expenditure is $400 to $600 million.  This tax expenditure was adopted in 1992 and does not have a sunset date.  This corporate excise expenditure is not a result of state conformity to the federal code.  The Commission assumes the goals of the expenditure include job creation and maintenance, investment, competitiveness/strategic, and avoiding taxation of mutual fund income at the entity and shareholder level.  The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the question of whether we can measure the overall benefit toward achieving the goals.  Natasha noted that it is difficult to quantify all the benefits related to the expenditure.  The Commission voted “strongly agree” on the question of whether the tax expenditure’s benefit justifies its fiscal cost.  Natasha highlighted that it is a meaningful incentive to have RIC’s (like Fidelity and State Street) either headquartered or operating in Massachusetts and that many households own shares of mutual funds or other RIC’s.  The Commission voted “somewhat agree” on the questions of whether (i) the tax expenditure is claimed by its intended beneficiaries and (ii) the tax expenditure is claimed by a broad group.  The Commission voted “strongly agree” on the questions of whether (i) the amount claimed per taxpayer is meaningful as an incentive/benefit, (ii) the tax expenditure is relevant today, and (iii) the tax expenditure is easily administered.  The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the questions of whether (i) the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to smaller businesses and (ii) the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to lower income taxpayers.  The Commission agreed that this tax expenditure should not be flagged for legislative review.  Natasha noted that there are not many small RICs and that individual investors are not typically lower income.  Chairperson Forter noted that while this tax expenditure is not a direct result of state conformity to the federal code, it does align with federal rules, which makes it harder to determine if the state benefit is meaningful as an incentive.  She suggested moving the rating on the question of whether the tax expenditure’s benefit justifies its fiscal cost from “strongly agree” to “somewhat agree”.  Natasha agreed with this change.  Chairperson Forter asked if members had any questions.  No questions from members.  Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the evaluation template.  Natasha seconded the motion.  The Commission voted to approve the evaluation template for 2.703 Exemption for Regulated Investment Companies with the change noted above.  Jamie Oppedisano abstained.

Chris Carlozzi led a discussion on 3.108 Exemption for Certain Precious Metals.  Sales of $1000 or more of certain precious metals, such as gold and silver coins, are exempt from the sales and use tax.  The annual cost of this expenditure is $15 to $17 million and it was adopted in 1987 with no sunset date.  This sales tax exemption is not a result of state conformity to the federal code.  Chris mentioned this exemption benefits those both buying and selling certain precious metals.  Chris highlighted that surrounding states had similar expenditures.  Some states, including Rhode Island, completely exempt such sales.  Other states require sales to exceed a certain dollar amount or level of precious metal content.  These states include California, Connecticut, and New York.  A few states, including Maine and Vermont, tax sales of precious metals.  The Commission voted “somewhat agree” on the questions of whether (i) we can measure the overall benefit toward achieving the goals, (ii) the tax expenditure’s benefit justifies its fiscal cost, (iii) the tax expenditure is claimed by its intended beneficiaries, (iv) the amount claimed per taxpayer is meaningful as an incentive/benefit, (v) the tax expenditure is relevant today, and (vi) the tax expenditure is easily administered.  The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the question of whether the tax expenditure is claimed by a broad group of taxpayers.  Chris noted that this expenditure is not targeted toward smaller businesses or lower income taxpayers.  The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the question of whether (i) the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to smaller businesses and (ii) the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to lower income taxpayers.  Chris noted that this expenditure is relatively straightforward compared to others that have been reviewed.  The Commission agreed that this tax expenditure should not be flagged for legislative review.  Chairperson Forter asked if members had any questions.  No questions from members.  Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the evaluation template.  Chris seconded the motion.  The Commission voted to approve the evaluation template for 3.108 Exemption for Certain Precious Metals as presented.

Andrew DeFalco led a discussion on 3.109 Exemption for Cement Mixers.  Andrew highlighted that this sales tax exemption is for barrel devices mounted on the back of cement mixer trucks and not for the trucks themselves.  The annual cost of this expenditure is $2.3 to $2.6 million and it was adopted in 1971 with no sunset date.  This expenditure is not a result of state conformity to the federal code.  Andrew noted that almost all states have some sort of general manufacturing and equipment exemptions and that Massachusetts exemptions generally apply to certain qualified business entities, such as this case with cement mixers.  The goal of these types of expenditures is avoiding tax pyramiding.  The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the questions of whether (i) we can measure the overall benefit toward achieving the goal, (ii) the tax expenditure’s benefit justifies its fiscal cost, (iii) the tax expenditure is claimed by a broad group of taxpayers, and (iv) the amount claimed per taxpayer is meaningful as an incentive/benefit.  Andrew noted that consumers of cement are also beneficiaries of this exemption, assuming that the cost savings for businesses result in reduced prices for consumers but that this data is hard to quantify.  The Commission voted “somewhat agree” on the questions of whether (i) the tax expenditure is claimed by its intended beneficiaries, (ii) the tax expenditure is relevant today, and (iii) the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to smaller businesses.  The Commission voted “strongly agree” on the question of whether the tax expenditure is easily administered.  Andrew highlighted the relatively low cost of this expenditure and that other states have expenditures that accomplish similar goals, but no other state has a specific exemption for cement mixers.  The Commission agreed that this tax expenditure should not be flagged for legislative review.  Andrew asked if members had any questions.  No questions from members.  Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the evaluation template.    Andrew seconded the motion.  The Commission voted to approve the evaluation template for 3.109 Exemption for Cement Mixers as presented. 

Tom Downes led a discussion on 1.611 and 2.614 and 3.004 Film Credit, Payroll and Production / Exemption for Sales to Motion Picture Production Companies (film production program).  The Commission voted between “somewhat disagree” and “strongly disagree” on the questions of whether (i) we can measure the overall benefit toward achieving the goals and (ii) the tax expenditure’s benefit justifies its fiscal cost.  Tom noted that there is a decent amount of evidence on the effect of film production incentives both nationally and in specific states like Massachusetts.  One study shows that the film production program increase employment in Massachusetts, but the economic impact is very small.  Other studies suggest a negative return on investment since most of the benefits go to out-of-state taxpayers.   A common theme among these studies is the assumption that it is likely these film productions would have occurred absent these incentives.  Most states have adopted film production programs.  Tom noted the relatively high cost of this expenditure, which is about $100 million to $117 million per year during FY23 to FY27.  The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the questions of whether (i) the tax expenditure is claimed by its intended beneficiaries, (ii) the tax expenditure is claimed by a broad group, and (iii) the tax expenditure is relevant today.  This expenditure was originally set to expire in 2023 but was made permanent.  Tom highlighted that residents of Massachusetts don’t receive much benefit from this incentive, and that most of the benefit goes to film producers in California, New York, and other states.  Tom reviewed the comment section of the evaluation template, “The Commission’s evaluation of the life sciences tax incentives highlighted the benefits of having an expert group, between the recipients and DOR, grant the credits.  Fixing the budget of the group caps the state’s liability.  In addition, having an expert group choosing recipients increases the likelihood the credit will be given to the productions most likely to generate benefits. Further, establishing a claw-back provision could be helpful.”  Jamie highlighted that a large portion of the benefits go to out-of-state feature film producers and that it would be interesting to take a closer look at the smaller production companies that have formed and operated in Massachusetts since these incentives were adopted.  Chris Carlozzi asked Tom whether the studies he referenced talked about the ripple effects of the film production program on certain industries that work within the film industry, such as craft services or lighting.  Tom noted that these effects are difficult to estimate and that some studies attempt to do this.  Chairperson Forter noted that DOR produces a Massachusetts Film Tax Incentive Report and that its findings are similar to those reports that Tom noted.  Kazim Ozyurt (DOR) provided a brief history on the findings of Massachusetts film tax incentive reports.  Natasha noted that DOR’s reports on film tax incentive reports take a deeper dive into the effect on surrounding industries, such as tourism.  She also noted that the film industry is a very visible industry which may influence popularity of film production programs.  Chairperson Forter noted that Massachusetts is one of the states where the agency with specific industry expertise is not the one administering the program; DOR is responsible for this task.  She noted that it would make sense for this expenditure to be administered by an agency with more expertise as well as have a cap on the program.  Natasha added if that were to be created by legislative mandate, she would also hope that it'd be really clear that whether the film production program is an incentive program or not, because that would be an important thing to go with the cap.  Jamie added that if such an approach were taken, presumably the legislature would want to zero in on prioritizing the growth of the local industry here, local jobs, in order to direct the film production program’s benefits to meet its intended goal as best we can.  Chairperson Forter suggested the Commission flag this expenditure for legislative review in light of the conflict between the economic concerns and policy view.  Tom and Jamie agreed.  Chairperson Forter asked members whether there were any concerns with flagging this expenditure.  No comments from members.  Chairperson Forter asked members whether there were any other comment or concerns with the evaluation template as presented.  No comments from members.  Kazim asked if the Commission flagged this expenditure for legislative review during the last evaluation cycle.  The Commission noted that it was previously flagged for legislative review.  During that time the expenditure was set to expire, but changes were made to make it permanent.  The Commission agreed that this expenditure should again be flagged for legislative review and noted the importance of reviewing tax expenditures on a periodic basis.  The Commission voted to approve the evaluation template for 1.611 and 2.614 and 3.004 Film Credit, Payroll and Production / Exemption for Sales to Motion Picture Production Companies as presented.

                        Chairperson Forter noted that the next Commission meeting is to be scheduled for September to review the next batch of expenditures, all of which have been previously reviewed by the Commission.  She asked members whether they had any questions.  No questions from members.  She thanked everyone for their contributions and adjourned the meeting at 12:04 PM.

Help Us Improve Mass.gov  with your feedback

Please do not include personal or contact information.
Feedback