Commission Members in Attendance:
- Chairperson Rebecca Forter, Designee, MA Department of Revenue
- Lindsay Janeczek, Designee, MA Auditor
- Senator James B. Eldridge, Senate Chair Joint Committee on Revenue
- Thomas Baranowski, Designee, House Chair Joint Committee on Revenue
- Andrew DeFalco, Designee, Senate Committee on Ways and Means
- Chris Carlozzi, Designee, Senate Minority Leader
- Jamie Oppedisano, Designee, House Minority Leader
- Professor Natasha Varyani, Member, Governor’s Appointee
- Professor Thomas Downes, Member, Governor’s Appointee
- Sue Perez, Designee, MA Treasurer
Commission Members Absent:
- Representative Aaron Michlewitz, Member, House Ways and Means Committee
Agenda Items:
- Meeting Agenda
- Draft Minutes
- June 12, 2026 Meeting
- Presentation of June tax expenditure evaluation ratings, discuss and vote on ratings
- 3.112 Exemption for Aircraft and Aircraft Parts
- 3.301 Exemption for Items Used in Making Clothing
- 3.411 Exemption for Certain Sales by Typographers, Compositors and Color Separators
- 3.421 Exemption for Films
- 3.601 Exemption for Casual or Isolated Sales
- 1.303 & 2.307 Modified Accelerated Depreciation on Buildings (other than Rental Housing)
- 1.304 & 2.305 Modified Accelerate Cost Recovery System (MACRS) for Equipment
Meeting Minutes:
The meeting via teleconference was called to order at 11:08 AM. Chairperson Forter welcomed Commission members, called roll, and a quorum was recognized. Chairperson Forter noted that Adrienne Viarengo has been appointed as the designee for Senator James B. Eldridge, Senate Chair Joint Committee on Revenue. Chairperson Forter put the Commission and public on notice that the meeting is recorded for the purpose of minutes. The recording of the meeting will be kept for public record and will not be deleted.
Chairperson Forter asked for any comments or questions on the June 12, 2026 meeting minutes. Members did not provide any comment or questions. Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the minutes. Jamie Oppedisano seconded the motion. Members were in favor of approving the June ‘26 meeting minutes as drafted. The meeting minutes will be posted to the TERC website.
Chairperson Forter led a discussion on 3.112 Exemption for Aircraft and Aircraft Parts. This tax expenditure was flagged for legislative review during the Commission’s last review. Chairperson Forter noted that this is a relatively significant expenditure with an annual cost of $17M to $21M during FY22 to FY27, but that the cost has decreased since the Commission’s last review, estimated to be $24M to $26M during FY19 to FY23. This expenditure was adopted in 2002 and it does not sunset. It's a sales tax exemption which means that it is not derived from the federal code. The goal is competitiveness; the exemption is trying to encourage the use of Massachusetts airports for repairs and most neighboring states also have this exemption. The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the question of whether we can measure the overall benefit toward achieving its goal. Chairperson Forter noted that during the Commission’s last review, they voted “strongly disagree” because the exemption is perhaps overbroad and maybe its goals could be accomplished by exempting only parts; various administrations have considered repealing the expenditure. The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the question whether the benefits justify the costs. The Commission voted “somewhat agree” on the question of whether it's claimed by its intended beneficiaries. The Commission voted “strongly disagree” on the question of whether the tax expenditure is claimed by a broad group. The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the questions of whether (i) the amount claimed per taxpayer is meaningful as an incentive/benefit, (ii) the tax expenditure is relevant today, and (iii) the tax expenditure is easily administered. The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the question of whether the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to smaller businesses but noted that smaller airports still benefit. Chairperson Forter reviewed the comment section of the template, “At the time of its enactment, advocates of this tax expenditure presented it as important to the competitiveness of community airports, representing that small aircraft owners would register planes in other states or fly to other states for repairs to avoid tax, depriving the local airports of business. As enacted, the tax expenditure appears overbroad with regard to this goal, as it applies to both commercial carriers using Logan Airport and private aircraft using smaller airports, and as the scope of the exemption adopted excludes sales of aircraft from tax as well as excluding repair parts. Additionally, while local airports are intended beneficiaries of this tax expenditure, aircraft owners who would owe tax in the absence of the tax expenditure are the primary beneficiaries.” Tom Downes asked whether we have any data on the extent to which the cost of the expenditure is attributable to Logan. Kazim Ozyurt (DOR) answered that level of data is unavailable, but the assumption is that the bulk of the cost is related to Logan. Chairperson Forter asked whether there were any other comments or questions. Tom Downes asked whether there was any data on how community airports have changed since the adoption of the tax expenditure and whether the Commission received feedback on its previous recommendations. Kazim answered that we do not have that data on hand and would have to conduct additional research. Chairperson Forter noted that DOR historically has not received feedback in response to the Commission’s reports. Chairperson Forter made a motion to flag the expenditure for legislative review particularly because the expenditure exempts aircraft sales in addition to parts and repairs. Natasha Varyani agreed, noting that Massachusetts has a large number of regional airports. The Commission agreed to add Natasha’s comment to the template and agreed that this expenditure should again be flagged for legislative review. Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the template with additional comments, Sue Perez seconded. Members voted to approve the evaluation template for 3.112 Exemption for Aircraft and Aircraft Parts with an additional comment.
Sue Perez led a discussion on 3.301 Exemption for Items Used in Making Clothing. This tax expenditure was not flagged for legislative review during the Commission’s last review. This exemption from sales and use tax has a negligible annual cost, was adopted in 1967 with no sunset date, and is not a result of conformity to the federal code. Sue noted that evaluation ratings are similar to the Commission’s last review. The Commission voted “somewhat agree” on the questions of whether (i) we can measure the overall benefit toward achieving the goals, (ii) the tax expenditure is claimed by a broad group, (iii) the amount claimed per taxpayer is meaningful as an incentive/benefit, (iii) the tax expenditure is relevant today, and (iv) the tax expenditure is beneficial to lower income taxpayers. The Commission voted “strongly agree” on the questions of whether (i) the benefit justifies the cost, (ii) the tax expenditure is claimed by its intended beneficiaries, and (iii) the tax expenditure is easily administered. Sue reviewed the comment section of the template, ”Consumer sales of clothing below $175 per item are exempt from MA sales/use tax. In the absence of an exemption for consumer sales of materials used to make clothing, sales of commercially produced clothing would be exempt while home-made clothes would carry a tax-burden. While fewer consumers may sew their own clothes today than at the time the tax expenditure was adopted, nevertheless, this tax expenditure creates a rough equity between these clothing produced commercially and clothing that is still produced by individuals.” The Commission voted not to flag this expenditure for legislative review. Chairperson Forter asked members whether they had any questions or comments; no response from members. Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the template. Jamie Oppedisano seconded. Members voted to approve the template for 3.301 Exemption for Items Used in Making Clothing as presented.
Sue Perez led a discussion on 3.411 Exemption for Certain Sales by Typographers, Compositors and Color Separators. This tax expenditure was not flagged for legislative review during the Commission’s last review. Sales by typographers, compositors or color separators of composed type, film positives and negatives and reproduction proofs, or the fabrication or transfer of such items to a printer, publisher, or manufacturer of folding boxes, for use in printing are exempt from sales and use tax. Note that such printing inputs may be transferred electronically. Such electronic transfers would not be taxable even without the exemption. The annual cost of the expenditure is $3.0M to $3.4M during FY23 to FY27. Sue noted that the cost has remained about the same since the Commission’s last review. This tax expenditure was adopted in 1979 with no sunset date. This tax expenditure is not a result of state conformity to the federal code. It's assumed that the goal of the expenditure is to encourage and support the printing and publishing industry and to prevent sales and use tax from being incorporated into the price of printed materials. The Commission voted “strongly disagree” on the questions of whether (i) we can measure the overall benefit toward achieving the goal, (ii) the tax expenditure is claimed by a broad group of taxpayers, and (iii) the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to lower income taxpayers. The Commission voted “somewhat agree” on the questions of whether (i) the benefit justifies its fiscal cost, (ii) the tax expenditure amount claimed per taxpayer is meaningful as an incentive/benefit (iii) the tax expenditure is relevant today, and (iv) the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to smaller businesses. The Commission voted “strongly agree” on the question of whether the tax expenditure is claimed by its intended beneficiaries. Sue noted that (i) 432 taxpayers are taking advantage of this exemption with a total of about 7400 employees and that (ii) neighboring states have a similar tax expenditure including Connecticut and Maine. Sue highlighted that printing may be associated with production of volatile organic compounds along with heavy metals from ink which may cause air and soil pollution. Chairperson Forter asked members whether they had any questions or comments; no response from members. Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the template. Natasha Varyani seconded the motion. Members voted to approve the template for 3.411 Exemption for Certain Sales by Typographers as presented.
Jamie Oppedisano and Chris Carlozzi led a discussion on 3.421 Exemption for Films. This tax expenditure was flagged for legislative review during the Commission’s last review. Motion picture films sold for commercial exhibition are exempt from sales and use tax. This tax expenditure was adopted in 1967 with no sunset date. The Commission assumes the goal of the expenditure is to exempt a key input from sales tax which might otherwise flow into the cost of admission which itself is specifically exempt. The Commission voted “strongly disagree” on the questions of whether (i) we can measure the overall benefit toward achieving the goal and (ii) the tax expenditure is claimed by a broad group of taxpayers. Jamie noted that it is difficult to estimate the annual cost due to limited data. The annual cost of the expenditure is estimated to be $2.6M. The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the questions of whether (i) the amount claimed per taxpayer is meaningful as an incentive/benefit and (ii) the tax expenditure is relevant today. The Commission voted “somewhat agree” on the questions of whether (i) the benefit justifies its fiscal cost, (ii) the tax expenditure is claimed by its intended beneficiaries, and (iii) the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to smaller businesses. The Commission voted “strongly agree” on the question of whether the tax expenditure is easily administered. Jamie reviewed the comment section of the template, “Due to limitations on the data available and reliance on external sources for the information, there is significant uncertainty in the tax revenue loss estimate. With advances in technology and the state of current industry practice, most content providers now use non-taxable digital versions of the films they show. There is some question whether the tax expenditure provides as meaningful a benefit as in the past, but it may still prove helpful to some smaller, independent exhibitors that compete with streaming services.” Jamie and Chris highlighted the exemption’s particular importance to small theaters and suggested not flagging this tax expenditure for legislative review. The Commission considered whether the rise in audiences watching films via non-taxable means (like streaming) may be a reason to maintain the exemption and noted the legislature may want to look at the expenditure from a new scope considering changes within the industry since the exemption was adopted. The Commission agreed to add a comment to this effect on the template. Chairperson Forter added that from a policy perspective it may be worthwhile to not flag the tax expenditure. Jamie added that the legislature will most likely encounter the same challenges the Commission had as it relates to calculating the cost of the expenditure. Chris agreed. Chairperson Forter asked members if they had any comments; no comments from members. Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the template with the additional comment that was agreed upon. Chris seconded. Members voted to approve the template for 3.421 Exemption for Films with the change noted above.
Andrew DeFalco led a discussion on 3.601 Exemption for Casual or Isolated Sales. This tax expenditure was not flagged for legislative review during the Commission’s last review. This exemption applies to casual and isolated sales which are sales that occur infrequently and outside the normal course of a seller’s business, such as tangible personal property (other than motor vehicles, trailers, boats, or airplanes) originally acquired for use or consumption by a seller and later resold by that seller. The annual cost of the expenditure is $35.6M to $42.3M and was adopted in 1978 without a sunset date. Andrew noted that evaluation ratings remain consistent with the Commission’s last review, except for the question of whether the tax expenditure’s benefit justifies its fiscal cost, which has moved from “somewhat disagree” to “somewhat agree”. Andrew highlighted that since 2019, Massachusetts has applied the state sales tax to remote sellers and marketplace facilitators with over $100,000 in sales in Massachusetts and that this change further limited the application of the expenditure to isolated or informal transactions between small scale transactors. Chairperson Forter suggested moving the rating on the question of whether the tax expenditure is easily administered from “strongly agree” to “somewhat disagree” due to difficulty with determining taxpayer eligibility. Chris asked whether it has become more difficult for DOR to administer over the years. Chairperson Forter answered that the difficulty has not increased since the Commission’s last review, but that DOR is taking a closer look at administrability during this evaluation cycle. Tom Downes suggested correcting the tax type on the template to reflect only sales tax. Chairperson Forter agreed to this change. Tom asked whether this exemption would apply to something like an Etsy store. Andrew noted the remote seller threshold adopted in 2019. Chairperson Forter asked members whether they had any other comments; no comments from members. Chairperson Forter made a motion to approve the template with the changes noted above. Andrew DeFalco seconded the motion. Members voted to approve the evaluation template for 3.601 Exemption for Casual or Isolated Sales with the changes noted above.
Tom Downes led a discussion on 1.303 & 2.307 Modified Accelerated Depreciation on Buildings (other than Rental Housing). This tax expenditure was not flagged for legislative review during the Commission’s last review. The annual cost of the expenditure is $2M to $110M for corporate excise and $5M to $105M for personal income tax during FY24 to FY28. Tom highlighted that the expenditure is challenging to administer in the short term because Massachusetts has decoupled from the federal government’s recent expansion of the set of buildings for which accelerated depreciation is allowed. Tom noted that modified accelerated depreciation was enacted at the federal level in 1986 and that there's some analysis that suggests that straight line depreciation favors equipment over buildings. The goals of the expenditure are competitiveness and encouraging investment. The Commission voted “somewhat disagree” on the questions of whether (i) we can measure the overall benefit, (ii) the benefit justifies the fiscal cost and (iii) the tax expenditure is easily administered. The Commission voted “somewhat agree” on the questions of whether (i) the tax expenditure is claimed by its intended beneficiaries and (ii) the tax expenditure is claimed by a broad group, (iii) the amount claimed per taxpayer is meaningful as an incentive/benefit, and (iv) the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to smaller businesses. The Commission voted “strongly agree” on the question of whether the tax expenditure is relevant today. The Commission voted “strongly disagree” on the question of whether the tax expenditure is primarily beneficial to lower income taxpayers. Most of the beneficiaries are high income taxpayers. Natasha Varyani and Tom noted that the legislature has had their eyes on this expenditure given that the state decided to decouple from recent federal changes. Members discussed the significant cost of the expenditure and whether flagging it for legislative review would be effective. Tom Chappell (DOR) noted that the federal change creates new administrative challenges whether the state conforms to them or not. Chairperson Forter suggested flagging the tax expenditure for legislative review and members agreed. Chairperson Forter made a motion to flag the expenditure and approve the template.Tom Downes seconded the motion. Members voted to approve the evaluation template for 1.303 & 2.307 Modified Accelerated Depreciation on Buildings (other than Rental Housing) with the expenditure flagged.
Natasha Varyani led a discussion on 1.304 & 2.305 Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS) for Equipment. This tax expenditure was not flagged for legislative review during the Commission’s last review. Natasha noted the similarities in the evaluation ratings and arguments between this expenditure and that which was just reviewed, 1.303 & 2.307 Modified Accelerated Depreciation on Buildings (other than Rental Housing). Changes in the One Big Beautiful Bill expanded coverage for federal rules. These changes were not picked up by Massachusetts, which poses new administrative challenges. Natasha suggested the expenditure be flagged for legislative review for the same reasons that the Commission flagged 1.303 & 2.307 Modified Accelerated Depreciation on Buildings (other than Rental Housing). Chairperson Forter agreed. Chairperson Forter asked members if they had any other comments. Natasha thanked Tom Downes for leading the review of these particularly detailed and challenging expenditures. Chairperson Forter made a motion to flag the expenditure and approve the template. Natasha Varyani seconded. Members approved the template for 1.304 & 2.305 Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS) for Equipment with the expenditure flagged.
Chairperson Forter noted that the next Commission meeting is to be scheduled for October to review the next batch of expenditures. All but two expenditures in the next batch have been previously reviewed by the Commission. Chairperson Forter asked members whether they had any questions; no questions from members. She thanked everyone for their contributions and adjourned the meeting at 12:04 PM.
| Last updated: | October 23, 2026 |
|---|