Historically, the Massachusetts Trial Court has collected and reported data on applications for complaint for youth in Juvenile Court broken down by how they are initiated: applications initiated by a custodial arrest, and applications initiated by a court summons. The Juvenile Justice Policy and Data Board (JJPAD) then collected, analyzed, and reported this data as part of its annual legislative report process. This data also has appeared in several OCA reports and presentations that leverage data collected and reported by the JJPAD Board.
In November 2026, the Trial Court informed the OCA of data quality concerns in the reporting of summons and arrests data for youth in Juvenile Court. Due to the nature of these concerns, the Trial Court made the decision to stop publishing data on arrests and summons for youth in Juvenile Court and to remove all historic data on arrests and summons from their Tableau Public page until such time as accurate data is available. The OCA has therefore also removed all data related to arrest and summons of youth in Juvenile Court from its public data dashboard Massachusetts Juvenile Justice System: Data and Outcomes for Youth.
The JJPAD began reporting data on arrests and summons in FY2022. Since then, this data has appeared in a number of JJPAD products, including:
- JJPAD Reports
- JJPAD Board meeting presentations
- Data Subcommittee meeting presentations
- CBI Subcommittee meeting presentations
JJPAD meetings operate under the open meeting law and the various reports and presentations are a matter of public record. Because they are historical materials of JJPAD meetings, the references to this data remain in the record. However, the OCA advises the public that the Trial Court, and thus the OCA, can no longer verify the accuracy of this set of data. Certain data takeaways contained in these reports, most notably findings related to any increase in the use of arrest vs summons, can no longer be verified. The OCA has now included disclaimers in the relevant reports of both the JJPAD and the OCA.
The OCA notes, however, that the JJPAD Board’s recommendations, included in numerous reports, for the Commonwealth to increase the use of diversion and/or summons for youth in Juvenile Court in lieu of arrest are rooted in a large body of research that demonstrates the harmful impacts of arrests on youth and the positive long-terms outcomes for young people and public safety resulting from diversion.
Until such time that accurate data on youth arrests and summons is made available to the OCA, the JJPAD Board will not publish arrests and summons data in future reports.