As administrator of the insurance laws, the Commissioner of Insurance conducts hearings and issues decisions on a wide range of topics, including statewide insurance rate cases, enforcement actions taken by the Division against its licensees, the financial control and structure of certain domestic insurers, and administrative appeals.
Copies of recent decisions are available in PDF format. These are not official copies of the decisions. Official copies are available at the Division and on reserve at the State House Library.
- This page, Division of Insurance Public Hearing Decisions, is offered by
- Division of Insurance
Division of Insurance Public Hearing Decisions
Table of Contents
Year 2023 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 150.39 KB,
C2023-01; CAR Performance Standards; Issued August 29, 2023
(English, PDF 150.39 KB)
Open PDF file, 252.43 KB,
R2022-02; WCRIB; Issued April 4, 2023
(English, PDF 252.43 KB)
Year 2022 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 236.85 KB,
E2021-01; Appeal of Jay Seitz; Issued June 9, 2022
(English, PDF 236.85 KB)
Open PDF file, 247.73 KB,
R2021-02; WCRIB; Issued April 22, 2022
(English, PDF 247.73 KB)
Open PDF file, 242.3 KB,
W2019-01; Appeal of Composite Company, Inc.; Issued February 9, 2022
(English, PDF 242.3 KB)
Year 2021 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 225.16 KB,
E2020-01; Division of Insurance v. Jay Seitz; Issued June 21, 2021
(English, PDF 225.16 KB)
Open PDF file, 153.97 KB,
C2020-01; CAR Performance Standards; Issued April 6, 2021
(English, PDF 153.97 KB)
Open PDF file, 186.98 KB,
E2019-09; Division of Insurance v. Kimberly Spears ; Issued April 1, 2021
(English, PDF 186.98 KB)
Year 2020 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 237.77 KB,
E2019-16; Division of Insurance v. Ryan Lewis; Issued August 12, 2020
(English, PDF 237.77 KB)
Open PDF file, 225.01 KB,
E2019-12; Division of Insurance v. Pankaj Chatwani; Issued June 17, 2020
(English, PDF 225.01 KB)
Open PDF file, 234.56 KB,
E2019-11; Division of Insurance v. Nakima K. Johnson; Issued June 17, 2020
(English, PDF 234.56 KB)
Open PDF file, 225.08 KB,
E2019-04; Division of Insurance v. Saul Suster; Issued June 17, 2020
(English, PDF 225.08 KB)
Open PDF file, 112.26 KB,
R2019-01; WCRIB Insurance Rate Filing; Issued March 27, 2020
(English, PDF 112.26 KB)
Year 2019 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 216.05 KB,
E2019-07; Division of Insurance v. Nikia Jones; Issued December 4, 2019
(English, PDF 216.05 KB)
Open PDF file, 234.77 KB,
E2019-06; Division of Insurance v. Alex Belfort; Issued October 21, 2019
(English, PDF 234.77 KB)
Open PDF file, 163.67 KB,
C2018-03; Point Ins Co Request for a Hearing; Issued October 21, 2019
(English, PDF 163.67 KB)
Open PDF file, 182.69 KB,
C2019-02; Appeal of Shannon Ins.; Issued October 18, 2019
(English, PDF 182.69 KB)
Open PDF file, 158.24 KB,
G2019-01; Kapinos Request for c. 176H, §14 Hearing; Issued May 17, 2019
(English, PDF 158.24 KB)
Open PDF file, 314.64 KB,
E2017-19; Division of Insurance v. Alex Drawve; Issued April 23, 2019
(English, PDF 314.64 KB)
Open PDF file, 227.75 KB,
E2018-11; Division of Insurance v. Logan Belmore; Issued April 12, 2019
(English, PDF 227.75 KB)
Open PDF file, 208.48 KB,
C2018-02; Proposed Changes to CAR Rule 29; Issued April 3, 2019
(English, PDF 208.48 KB)
Open PDF file, 311.5 KB,
E2018-03; Division of Insurance v. Kotera Heard; Issued March 29, 2019
(English, PDF 311.5 KB)
Year 2018 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 230.43 KB,
E2017-13; Division of Insurance v. Chandra Barr; Issued December 27, 2018
(English, PDF 230.43 KB)
Open PDF file, 227.74 KB,
E2017-12; Division of Insurance v. Deise Brito; Issued December 26, 2018
(English, PDF 227.74 KB)
Open PDF file, 282.03 KB,
W2017-01; Appeal of Tony’s Bakery; Issued August 28, 2018
(English, PDF 282.03 KB)
Open PDF file, 229.61 KB,
E2017-06; Division of Insurance v. Michael Tarantino; Issued July 9, 2018
(English, PDF 229.61 KB)
Open PDF file, 216.98 KB,
E2017-16; Division of Insurance v. Paul E. Smyth; Issued July 6, 2018
(English, PDF 216.98 KB)
Open PDF file, 220.27 KB,
R2017-01; WCRIB of MA Insurance Rate Filing; Issued March 21, 2018
(English, PDF 220.27 KB)
Year 2017 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 226.28 KB,
E2016-16; Division of Insurance v. Valenzia Ramsey; Issued Dec. 6, 2017
(English, PDF 226.28 KB)
Open PDF file, 227.98 KB,
E2016-17; Division of Insurance v. Joshua A. Vela ; Issued Dec. 6, 2017
(English, PDF 227.98 KB)
Open PDF file, 230.71 KB,
E2016-18; Division of Insurance v. Rodolfo Jimenez; Issued Dec. 6, 2017
(English, PDF 230.71 KB)
Open PDF file, 222.27 KB,
E2017-05; Division of Insurance v. Sherika Brantley; Issued Dec. 6, 2017
(English, PDF 222.27 KB)
Open PDF file, 221.27 KB,
E2017-09; Division of Insurance v. Danielle Halfon; Issued Dec. 6, 2017
(English, PDF 221.27 KB)
Year 2016 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 272.73 KB,
R2016-01 WCRIBMA Filing for Revisions to Manual; Issued September 16, 2016
(English, PDF 272.73 KB)
Open PDF file, 235.28 KB,
E2016-03; Division of Insurance v. Jeffrey B. Cohen ; Issued July 15, 2016
(English, PDF 235.28 KB)
Open PDF file, 232.8 KB,
E2016-06; Division of Insurance v. Sean Green; Issued July 15, 2016
(English, PDF 232.8 KB)
Open PDF file, 28.83 KB,
C2015-01; Performance Standards; Issued May 31, 2016
(English, PDF 28.83 KB)
Open PDF file, 41.61 KB,
C2016-01; CAR Rule 29; Issued May 31, 2016
(English, PDF 41.61 KB)
Open PDF file, 30.24 KB,
R2015-02; WCRIB Rate Filing; Issued April 20, 2016
(English, PDF 30.24 KB)
Open PDF file, 82.47 KB,
E2014-13; Division of Insurance v. Betsy Burgos; Issued January 7, 2016
(English, PDF 82.47 KB)
Year 2015 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 171.89 KB,
E2015-02; Division of Insurance v. Keely Grimes; Issued December 17, 2015
(English, PDF 171.89 KB)
Open PDF file, 29.08 KB,
R2014-02; MPIUA Dwelling Liability Rate Filing; issued March 24, 2015
(English, PDF 29.08 KB)
Year 2014 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 49.67 KB,
E2014-07; Division of Insurance v. Jorge A. Pena; issued August 6, 2014
(English, PDF 49.67 KB)
Open PDF file, 43.99 KB,
E2014-03; Division of Insurance v. Edna D. Duvall; issued June 4, 2014
(English, PDF 43.99 KB)
Open PDF file, 47.37 KB,
E2014-01; Division of Insurance v. Richard Hayward; issued June 4, 2014
(English, PDF 47.37 KB)
Open PDF file, 46.53 KB,
E2013-11; Division of Insurance v. Nancy Hutchinson; issued May 6, 2014
(English, PDF 46.53 KB)
Year 2013 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 36.73 KB,
E2013-06; Division of Insurance v. Hope Allen; Issued June 10, 2013
(English, PDF 36.73 KB)
Open PDF file, 158.84 KB,
E2012-10; Division of Insurance v. Lester Williams; Issued March 13, 2013
(English, PDF 158.84 KB)
Year 2012 Public Hearing Decisions
Year 2011 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 46.31 KB,
E2011-04; Paul Burke v. Division of Insurance; Issued June 22, 2011
(English, PDF 46.31 KB)
Year 2010 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 51.12 KB,
E2010-05; Division of Insurance v. Dana Brett Polk; Issued June 7, 2010
(English, PDF 51.12 KB)
Open PDF file, 47.63 KB,
E2009-15; Division of Insurance v. Kevin E. Brown; Issued March 8, 2010
(English, PDF 47.63 KB)
Year 2009 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 47.08 KB,
E2009-04; Division of Insurance v. Eleasar Fraga; Issued May 6, 2009
(English, PDF 47.08 KB)
Open PDF file, 40.73 KB,
E2009-03; Division of Insurance v. Lisa Sue Mize; Issued April 13, 2009
(English, PDF 40.73 KB)
Year 2008 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 42.48 KB,
E2008-10; Division of Insurance v. Kiana C. Mims; Issued August 5, 2008
(English, PDF 42.48 KB)
Open PDF file, 38.99 KB,
E2008-07; Division of Insurance v. Peter Tzamalas; Issued June 12, 2008
(English, PDF 38.99 KB)
Open PDF file, 515.67 KB,
E2007-06; John C. Magennis v. Division of Insurance; Issued April 25, 2008
(English, PDF 515.67 KB)
Open PDF file, 76.2 KB,
Appendix "A" to the CAR Decision (C2007-03); Issued January 2, 2008
(English, PDF 76.2 KB)
Year 2007 Public Hearing Decisions
Year 2006 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 1.05 MB,
Transitional and MAIP Rules
(English, PDF 1.05 MB)
Open PDF file, 114.82 KB,
E2005-28; Division of Insurance v. William F. Tracy; Issued August 4, 2006
(English, PDF 114.82 KB)
Open PDF file, 119.83 KB,
E2006-07; Division of Insurance v. Teresa Ann Healey; Issued July 13, 2006
(English, PDF 119.83 KB)
Open PDF file, 117.47 KB,
E2006-05; Division of Insurance v. Glen D. Tucker; Issued May 5, 2006
(English, PDF 117.47 KB)
Open PDF file, 117.47 KB,
E2006-04; Division of Insurance v. Tyler Parker Turner; Issued May 5, 2006
(English, PDF 117.47 KB)
Open PDF file, 114.65 KB,
E2005-26; Division of Insurance v. Martin O'Malley; Issued March 16, 2006
(English, PDF 114.65 KB)
Year 2005 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 194.83 KB,
E2004-24; Division of Insurance v. Neale; Issued April 4, 2005
(English, PDF 194.83 KB)
Year 2004 Public Hearing Decisions
Open PDF file, 1.88 MB,
Transitional and MAIP Rules
(English, PDF 1.88 MB)
Open PDF file, 1016.88 KB,
Transitional and MAIP Rules - Redlined
(English, PDF 1016.88 KB)
Open PDF file, 934.96 KB,
C2004-02; CAR - Rules of Operation; Issued September 24, 2004
(English, PDF 934.96 KB)
Help Us Improve Mass.gov with your feedback
Thank you for your website feedback! We will use this information to improve this page.
If you would like to continue helping us improve Mass.gov, join our user panel to test new features for the site.